Are cryptocurrencies the new dotcom stocks?

Buying bitcoins on a computer © Getty Images
Cryptocurrencies: exciting, but very risky

You’ve heard of bitcoin, right.

But what about namecoin? Or novacoin? Or even quarkcoin?

Get with the coins, guys! Cryptocurrencies are the new dotcom.

The wild world of cryptocurrencies

Namecoin was up 120% yesterday. Not last year, or last month, but yesterday.

Novacoin? That was up 185%. Quarkcoin? 230%.

But the big mover, well, that was craftcoin. That was up 1,557.8%. In one day.

I doubt even the bloke who discovered Ghawar (the world’s largest oil field) saw daily gains like that.

Yesterday I went to meet a private investor who makes his living speculating in cryptocurrencies. We had met virtually a few years ago, in 2010 (I think). He got in touch and gave me a couple of bitcoins – he was living with ‘one of the blokes who developed them’.

So I had plenty to thank him for when I met him again. “Oh, don’t worry about it”, he said. “You should take a look at worldcoin now.”

“Worldcoin?” Some fiddling on a computer and he gave me a thousand of them. “Thanks again!” I say.

“Oh, it’s all right. I want to get the word out. The more people I give them to, the more people’ll talk about them. I’ve got a million of them.”

“A million! A what price?”

“About 2p.”

“What’re they worth now?”

“About 5 or 6p. They could go to any number. Depends how they catch on. Or they could go to nothing. I like to take big risks.”

Worldcoin, by the way, was ‘only’ up 21% yesterday. Its market cap – the worth of the entire currency – is now $3.87m – with about 32.5 million of the coins in existence.

Bitcoin’s market cap is about $10.7bn – they’re trading near $900 a piece and there are 12 million of them. (Remember two weeks ago when I urged caution? It’s more than doubled since then).

“So why’s worldcoin better than bitcoin?”

“The transaction times are faster”, he replied.

“How do you buy them?”

“Well, you need bitcoins. You swap your fiat for bitcoin and then you go to a crypto-exchange and swap your bitcoins for some other cryptocoin”.

I loved the casual and rather dismissive way he said ‘fiat’, rather than any specific government currency.

This partly explains why bitcoin remains the dominant cryptocurrency – it’s the main portal between ‘fiat’ and ‘crypto’. It also has first-mover advantage. While it can take as little as three days to design and build a cryptocurrency (so my friend tells me), what takes longer is the construction of all the accompanying websites and services. For example, you can’t yet buy bitcoins with a credit card, as you would an item off Amazon. You have to deposit your money with an exchange, and wait for it to clear.

But there are bound to be better cryptocurrencies, ones that copy bitcoin’s strengths and improve on its shortcomings. How do we know which are the good ones that will thrive?

“Some have their own unique selling points,” said my friend. “Primecoin helps discover long chains of prime numbers as a by-product of its computing. Namecoin’s supposed to reduce internet censorship. Litecoin is the next biggest after bitcoin. Feathercoin’s had a lot of publicity.’

“Yeah, but what are the good ones?”

“I’ve told you. I put my money in worldcoin.”

Cryptocurrencies are exciting but extremely risky

So what are the risks? Governments are a potential problem. If cryptocurrencies start to present a real threat to fiat money, you can be sure governments will fight them through regulation and taxation.

“Yeah, but they’re slower than we are. They might win the odd battle, but they won’t win the war. If you want to corrupt a cryptocurrency and mess it up you need to control 51% of the mining power. Already it would apparently cost half a trillion in computer power to stage a 51% attack on bitcoin.”

A bigger issue is that while cryptocurrencies remain anonymous, there can be no customer protection. There is no deposit insurance. Just yesterday it was revealed that Denmark’s Bitcoin Internet Payment Services lost $1m-worth of bitcoins in a raid that took place over the course of the past several days.

My friend lost 90 bitcoins in a raid a year ago. I do a quick sum in my head. “That’s 80-odd grand!”

“Yeah, I’m not happy about it.”

Another worry is the old-fashioned pump and dump. There are more than 90 different cryptocurrencies in existence. Anyone can start a currency. Once it exists, users promote and promote it. My friend is quite open about the fact that this is what he is doing with worldcoin.

“You often don’t know who’s behind a coin,” he says. “It could just be some dude with a computer in Timbuktu. If he decides to pull the plug and turn the website off, there’s not a lot you can do about it”.

So it really is the Wild West out there.

Meanwhile, in the comments section of one of my other articles on bitcoin, one poster wrote that he was having trouble getting his money out of Mt Gox (the world’s largest bitcoin exchange). He is not alone. Indeed, it seems a lot of money is going into crypto, fortunes are being made, but not a lot is coming out.

But the more widespread cryptocurrencies become, the more people will come up with ways to deal with these problems. For example, my friend is importing a bitcoin ATM. “I’m going to be the first. You’ll be able to swap bitcoins for cash, or cash for bitcoins.” It’s not unlike the early days of the internet – moving from a wild badlands populated by a few hardcore pioneers, to the more user-friendly mainstream.


Compare the UK's leading gold brokers gold-safe-120x120

If you're interested in buying gold, our up-to-date directory of the foremost gold brokers and ETF funds makes essential reading.

Gold broker comparison table


Bubbles are usually built on some revolutionary new technology. Whether it’s railroads or automobiles or dotcom. This bubble has the potential to be bigger than all of them. Money is involved in every transaction we make. I watched a talk by Conservative MP Douglas Carswell at the Russian Embassy on Monday night. Carswell too is convinced that, just as happened with music and books, with retailing and information, digital technology will revolutionise money. Banks and governments will lose their monopoly.

And as the Atlas Pulse newsletter observes, whether it was gold in the ‘70s, Japan in the ‘80s or dotcom in the ‘90s, each bubble grew to a value equivalent to the entire S&P. You ask how big cryptocurrencies can go? The S&P is worth about $21 trillion. Cryptocurrencies are worth a total of about $11bn or $12bn – there’s a lot of upside.

But the problem cryptocurrencies must overcome is that, like the mining boom of the last decade, pump-and-dump is rife. Cryptocurrencies have become speculative assets. They’re supposed to be mediums of exchange.

Despite the bubble in automobiles, just three major car companies remain in the US. Companies like Google and Facebook came after the dotcom bust. AOL was the leader before. How influential is AOL now? Is bitcoin the next AOL? Does the Google of cryptocurrencies even exist yet?

“What are you going to do with your cryptocurrency profits?” I ask my friend.

“Buy gold.”

And he wasn’t joking. Funny how these things come full circle.

• Life After The State by Dominic Frisby is available at Amazon. An audiobook version is available here.

• Follow @dominicfrisby on Twitter.

This article is taken from our FREE daily investment email Money Morning.
Receive our thought-provoking investment email every weekday morning plus occasional promotions & become a smarter investor.

Please enter a valid email address

To sign-up enter your email address.


• Stay up to date with MoneyWeek: Follow us on TwitterFacebook and Google+

Our recommended articles for today

The unbeatable tax advantage landlords have over first-time buyers

Our tax system massively favours buy-to-let property buyers over those looking to secure their first home, says Merryn Somerset Webb.

Central America: violent, impoverished – and attracting billions

The countries of Central America are undergoing serious changes, says James McKeigue. It’s becoming a region where investors stand to make big money.

9 Responses

  1. 27/11/2013, MRSC wrote

    What an entertaining article. Look forward to hearing you again soon on Max.

  2. 27/11/2013, Daniel Victor wrote

    Nice article.If Bitcoin were secure in its dominant position then it would still be a ‘buy’ due to the limitations on its supply and the way in which it allows the transfer of wealth without bureaucracy.However,alternative cryptocurrencies are its achilles heel.

  3. 27/11/2013, Julian Jessop wrote

    A really interesting, informative and wittily constructed piece with a classic Frisby punchline.

    Great stuff, and reassuring to conservative investors like myself after gold’s poor run lately.

  4. 27/11/2013, RHT wrote

    Hi Dominic,

    I read your crypto article with very great interest today. I’m looking to launch
    ‘ Africancoin ‘ – Africancoin.com, as a crypto-digital currency but need some advise and possibly partners on this. Would you mind passing on my email to your friend: robert(AT)blackworld.com , if thats ok with you?. Africancoin can stand out remarkably from all the rest due to emerging economies in Africa and natural commodity resources. Africancoin as a digital currency will be powered by our media platform Blackworld.com which already has considerable global traction. I also have another bitcoin startup play called BitnPay.com, which I want to develop as the Google for Bitcoin, more focused on how consumers spend their bitcoins. The opportunities are truly awesome and Silicon Valley VC is pouring in to Bitcoin and crypto-currencies like web 1.0 all over again. It would be very nice to partner with players here in the UK for a change wherever possible. Here’s my linkedin for further perusal: http://www.linkedin.com/in/roberthaastruptimmi/

    Awesome article Dominic. Thanks very much indeed!

  5. 27/11/2013, CH wrote

    Finally it has dawned…… Anyone can create a virtual currency. Whereas real money (precious metals) cannot be created by human ingenuity.

  6. 27/11/2013, sigcima wrote

    Oh dear -flaky to say the least (not the article but the “wild west”;

    “mcxNOW is shutting down for a period of time

    Withdraw all your coins before December 20th

    mcxNOW has seen unprecedented growth in recent months and especially in the last few weeks. mcxNOW is a custom coded exchange built 100% by one man in C++ . This means if anything has to be modified then only one person can do it.

    Unfortunately the growth has been too fast to match with the support requirement as only one person can currently do all support. This is a burden of 200 to 400 emails a day among many requests on IRC and through chat. This makes development of mcxNOW nearly impossible without neglecting valid user requests through support.

    I am happy that in over 7 months mcxNOW has not been hacked or lost any coins and that the exchange has scaled well from 100 users upto a peak of about 3500 users online at once, it shows the design here is pretty good. However I never anticipated some aspects of running an exchange that are quite important (ie. support) so I need to work on this before allowing the site to grow.

    I advise everyone to withdraw their coins and use other exchanges until mcxNOW returns. I will need at least one month, and perhaps as many as 3 before I can make the site live again. If you fail to withdraw coins before December 20th then you’ll have to wait until the site is live again before withdrawing, whatever balance you hold will carry over. After December 20th passes a test version of mcxNOW will be put up that you can help test without using real coins, this will include the new gaming platform.

    All existing mcxFEE holders will have the same mcxFEE balance when the site relaunches. I’m allowing people to trade mcxFEE up until December 20th in case they want to exit them.

    I apologize for needing to do this, the stress and burden of running a successful exchange in the current way is just untenable for me now. I can barely sleep, I am getting health issues, etc. There truly is no alternative than some downtime. I apologize mainly to mcxFEE holders as they have invested in the exchange and will miss revenue in the downtime.

    mcxNOW will be back and even better than before, I truly believe we have the best trading platform and cryptocommunity platform here but I need to work on these other facets before it becomes a real problem. I will use all the knowledge I have gathered over the last 7 months to make something bulletproof and easy to maintain.

    Thank you for your support and hopefully we can see all of you back here relatively soon.”

    https://mcxnow.com/

  7. 29/11/2013, nuxusr wrote

    mcxNOW is closing for a month, but in the meantime Cryptsy is a good place to trade (www.cryptsy.com). They are based in the US and there are faces and names behind the people running it. Also, +1 for the worldcoin. A companion site is launching soon that will accept USD (http://www.worldcoinfoundation.org/news/latest-worldcoin-project-scharmbeck-unveiled).

  8. 06/12/2013, DAS1951 wrote

    You all, journalists included, need to take stock (hohoho):

    http://www.zdnet.com/bitcoin-its-not-just-loopy-tulip-land-its-worse-7000024009/?s_cid=e539&ttag=e539

  9. 25/12/2013, budfox26 wrote

    The digital currency boom will be as big as the dot-com boom.

    http://www.alexlewicki.com/3-alternative-digital-currencies-that-should-be-in-your-wallet/

Commenting on this article closed

MoneyWeek magazine

Latest issue:

Magazine cover
Heading higher?

Or are house prices set to fall?

The UK's best-selling financial magazine. Take a FREE trial today.
Claim 4 FREE Issues

'Would you rather upset God, or have Him just ignore you?'

In the first of three interviews with Merryn Somerset Webb, Hugh Hendry, manager of the Eclectica Fund, talks about what it takes to be a good hedge fund manager – and how he learned to stop worrying and love central banks.


Which investment platform?

When it comes to buying shares and funds, there are several investment platforms and brokers to choose from. They all offer various fee structures to suit individual investing habits.
Find out which one is best for you.


21 November 1969: The first permanent Arpanet link

A milestone in the formation of the internet, the first permanent Arpanet link was established on this day in 1969 between researchers in the United States.