Why a short-selling ban won't work

Tim Bennett explains the practice of short selling shares - and why a ban may do more harm than good.

Tim Bennett explains the practice of short selling shares - and why a ban may do more harm than good.

Short- selling: should it be banned, is there any point in banning short-selling? Tim Bennett argues that no, there isn't, as it does more harm than good.

falling

How does short-selling work?

  1. The hedge fund borrows 10,000 shares from the pension fund, with the agreement that the hedge fund will pay a fee for lending the shares.
  2. The hedge fund, with the shares, sells them at, let's say £2 each, in the stock market.
  3. The hedge fund waits until the price has fallen, then buys the shares back at, say £1 each.
  4. The pension fund gets its 10,000 shares back plus the lending fee. These don't need to be the same 10,000 shares, as long as it's the same number of shares.
  5. If prices fall and the hedge fund makes the profit of £1 per share, it's made a profit of £10,000, minus the lending fee.

Why ban short-selling?

Are these countries right to ban short-selling?

No, there are two problems:1. The way it has been implemented is flawed

The mechanics don't work: four countries will outlaw this practice, because it drives down share prices. They accuse hedge funds of betting on prices falling, and therefore accentuating the falling prices of certain bank stocks. Will it work?

It's only a partial ban across four countries, so some hedge funds will simply move to jurisdictions that haven't banned short-selling. Equally, only banning a few stocks will just target the short sellers' attention on the other stocks.Also, what is going to be banned? You can't ban short-selling via shares, because of derivative contracts that allow people to short sell. Is it enough to just ban short-selling of shares, or do they need to widen the ban, and to cover what?

2. The principle of banning short-selling is wrong.

Short-selling is risky, and if it backfires, the people who do it pay a hefty penalty.

In the example above, if the price doesn't fall, and the price doubles, you would have to buy the shares back at a higher price, and this could take a long time to find someone to buy these shares back from.

Short sellers have a good reason to do what they do: if a share price is falling, it's not due to short sellers, it's due to the bank being badly run. And if you ban an activity that lots of people use in the markets as a trading tool, you reduce the number of trades and increase volatility.

The point of a short-selling ban is to stop share prices falling, but it doesn't work: hedge funds need to be able to run long and short positions, in order to hedge existing exposures.

Sometimes the motive behind short-selling is simply hedging, which is something a lot of funds need to be able to do. Closing that down, effectively makes the market less efficient than it should be.

Recommended

Why we should scrap the Budget
Budget

Why we should scrap the Budget

The yearly Budget, big set-piece of British politics, encourages the very worst from the government, says Matthew Lynn.
24 Oct 2021
Why fed-up workers are quitting their jobs
Economy

Why fed-up workers are quitting their jobs

Workers are leaving their jobs at an astonishing rate, especially in the US, leading to a shortage of workers. What will that mean for our economies? …
22 Oct 2021
Will the government’s green plans hit the price of your home?
House prices

Will the government’s green plans hit the price of your home?

UK house prices are still rising fast. But the government’s plan to reach net-zero carbon emissions could halt that – for some of us, at least. John S…
21 Oct 2021
From an age of plenty to an age of shortage
Economy

From an age of plenty to an age of shortage

We have emerged from the pandemic into a world where supply can’t meet demand, driving prices up. Merryn Somerset Webb looks at what's going on.
15 Oct 2021

Most Popular

How to invest as we move to a hydrogen economy
Energy

How to invest as we move to a hydrogen economy

The government has started to roll out its plans for switching us over from fossil fuels to hydrogen and renewable energy. Should investors buy in? St…
8 Oct 2021
Properties for sale for around £1m
Houses for sale

Properties for sale for around £1m

From a stone-built farmhouse in the Snowdonia National Park, to a Victorian terraced house close to London’s Regent’s Canal, eight of the best propert…
15 Oct 2021
How to invest in SMRs – the future of green energy
Energy

How to invest in SMRs – the future of green energy

The UK’s electricity supply needs to be more robust for days when the wind doesn’t blow. We need nuclear power, says Dominic Frisby. And the future of…
6 Oct 2021