The Dow Jones index rallies on fumes

I have neglected the Dow lately because there were more pressing markets to cover. But today, I thought I would analyse the Dow since it is now giving me some important trading signals.

On 18 December, when I last wrote on the Dow, the market was expecting the Fed to announce their intentions regarding a possible tapering of their quantitative easing (QE) programme. And sure enough, they did say they would scale back their bond purchases by $10bn a month until the end of 2014, when the buying will cease altogether.

The reaction of the market was generally positive. The Dow rallied on the news, and the US markets have maintained their strength since then. The Dow, the Nasdaq and the S&P have made new highs. And on 31 December, the Dow closed the year at an all-time high of 16,600.

But when the market re-opened on 2 January, the Dow opened with a large gap to the downside. So why the change of heart in the new year? While the Nasdaq and S&P have since gone on to make even higher highs, the Dow has not. So far, the 31 December high at 16,600 still holds. Can we make anything of this divergence?

The bigger picture

Let’s recap what the big picture looks like:

Dow Jones spread betting chart

Here are my long-term tramlines on the daily chart going back to 2011. There is a terrific upper tramline with multiple PPPs (prior pivot points). The December rally high took the market to a precise hit on this line, fully respecting it as a level of strong resistance which has lasted for over two years.

Here is a close-up of the tramline hit:

Dow Jones spread betting chart

And here is the recent trading on the hourly chart:

Dow Jones spread betting chart

Since early January, the market has been supported by the Fibonacci 23% support level. But that support finally failed and it rapidly declined to the next level at the 38% retracement. From there it staged the latest rally, which has not carried to a new high.

Finding a touch point for your tramlines

Because the market has been in a minor downtrend since 31 December, are there any tramlines I can draw?

Dow Jones spread betting chart

I have a terrific tramline pair where the market has rallied to the upper line (resistance) and then has been turned back. My lower line is significant because I have the start of the gap as a touch point. Because gaps are very rare, they can be normally used as a touch point for your tramlines.

As a case in point, here is the Nikkei over the same period:

Nikkei spread betting chart

I have my lower tramline with its fine PPP and the sole touch point is the major low. Then, my upper tramline has the two minor highs and the opening year’s gap as touch points.

Comparing the two markets, they are similar in outline but differ in the details.

The lesson is this: when you have a gap on a chart, you can use either end as a touch point for a tramline.

Making the case for a third wave decline

Back to the Dow and the Wednesday touch on the upper tramline, which was a possible short-trade entry. This was at low risk because the protective stop could be placed just above the line.

As for the Elliott waves (EW) here, I can make a case that we are on the verge of a third wave decline of several degrees. If you recall, I have noted that when the Dow has staged a decent decline, there were deep retracements before the decline could get under way. And this may be happening here.

Dow Jones spread betting chart

Here is a credible EW count with two 1-2s working. The second waves have both deeply retraced the first waves. But to confirm this count, the market will need to move rapidly down to the lower tramline to produce the characteristic long and strong move of a third wave.

That action would then place the 31 December high as the top.

But if the market fails to do this and moves back up to challenge the upper line again, the odds would swing to a break of the upper tramline and on to a new high.

Why this bull market is not unloved

As background, despite what is often said in the media, this bull market is not unloved when judged by the COT (commitments of traders) and internal sentiment data.

For instance, the NYSE margin debt has just hit an all-time high, which highlights the extreme optimism of the bulls. Money to buy shares is not borrowed when stocks are unloved!

And since last October, the New Highs Minus New Lows figures on the NYSE has been lagging the market in a very large divergence. The latest rally has been driven by fewer and fewer individual stocks making new highs.

This is a sign of a very tired bull market. And that means when the turn does arrive, it will be sharp and swift.


  • Mr Sceptical

    Well, there’s a surprise John. Another prediction of a Dow market top and a swift and sharp decline. How many is that over the last 2 years? And just look at the graph over the same period. The momentum traders must be laughing all the way to the bank.

  • Bronco Bill

    Keeping in mind John that 80% of gaps get filled I think the one where you have shown “top” possibly will get filled.
    On my 2hr chart the BBands are getting very narrow which suggests a big move coming up with the gap getting filled at around the top of the BBand first, and then….?
    A friend of mine has his pension invested and asked me for my thoughts for the long-term. I showed him monthly charts for the FTSE, Dow and S&P, (which are obviously nigh on all the same) and why he needs to think carefully.
    The highs made in 1999, 2007 and the recent high are diverging with momentum indicators showing lower peaks and as you say John the rallies are on fumes, not least the one from 2009.
    Between the years 2000/2001 and 2007/2008 with a gap of 7 years big downlegs started. We have now reached another 7 year gap between 2007/2008 and 2014/2015. Will we see a repeat?
    I believe a top will be made this year (if not allready) which will shock many, but not I hope to readers of your articles John.
    My friend has to make up his own mind, but I did say I would rather be wrong and out than right and in.

  • Computer Programmer Guru

    I Agree on the 31/12 high or just another minor pop higher this week or next, not sure what will cause the big fall that the charts are screaming about, but maybe it is obvious and we need not look further than the fumes of QE dissipating?