Short Wayfair: home furniture won’t deliver

Online furniture retailer Wayfair is chronically unprofitable and faces too much competition, says Matthew Partridge.

One of the most volatile stocks over the past 18 months has been the American online retailer Wayfair (NYSE: W). It nearly tripled from $66 in April 2018, reaching a peak of $171 in March. However, since then the stock has tumbled to $105, a drop of around 40% from its spring peak. It's easy to see why the market used to be so enthusiastic about the group. It has been growing so quickly that sales are expected to be over ten times higher this year than in 2013.

Wayfair suffers from poor profitability

However, if you take a closer look, it's even easier to spot why investors have started to get cold feet. For one thing, the company has a poor record when it comes to turning sales into actual profits. Indeed, the tenfold increase in sales has been outweighed by a 15-fold increase in losses per share. Even though analysts expect the losses to shrink slightly over the next few years, they will still be ten times their 2013 level. The company is also in the horrible position of having negative net assets: its debts are $605m greater than its assets.

Wayfair's losses aren't particularly surprising when you consider that its main business is selling home furniture, a difficult market to make money from consistently.

Consumers tend to spend a long time shopping around for the best deal before committing to a purchase and a large percentage of goods tend to be returned. What's more, Wayfair is far from the only company in this rather crowded market. Not only does it face competition from the established "big box" physical retailers such as The Home Depot and Bed Bath and Beyond, which are still a force in US retail, but it also has to find a way to fend off online competition from Amazon.

In addition to facing strong competition, Wayfair is vulnerable to any economic turbulence in the US in the near future. As you'd expect, there is a strong historical link between home furniture and housing sales, so if the American housing market starts to stumble then demand for home furnishings could fall. Both house sales and prices are still increasing, but the rate of growth has slowed considerably, and surveys suggest that consumers and homebuyers are increasingly worried about what's going to happen over the next year. Nobel laureate Robert Shiller expects prices to start falling.

The upshot is that while Wayfair's shares have fallen a lot, I think that they will continue to decline. I suggest that you short it at the current price of $105, at £33 per $1 (compared with IG Index's minimum price of £9 per $1), covering your position if Wayfair rises above $135. This gives you a total downside of £990.

How my tips have fared

Over the last fortnight six out of my eight long tips have risen. JD Sports has increased from 750p to 769p, Safestore from 671p to 692p and Superdry from 423p to 439p.

Bausch Health Companies has increased from $20.59 to $20.91. Volkswagen has also moved up, from €153 to €163, while International Consolidated Airline Group has climbed too, from 468p to 502p.

Sadly, however, Bellway has dropped from 3,354p to 3,291p and Ted Baker has collapsed from 925p to 494p, triggering the stop-loss at 709p. Overall, my long tips are making a profit of £2,358, down from £2,856.

My short tips have also had mixed results. While there hasn't been a dramatic Ted Baker-style reversal, three out of the five tips have appreciated. Tesla went up from $241 to $257, Netflix also increased from $266 to $286 and Uber advanced from $29.64 to $31.12.

Meanwhile, Weis Markets fell from $38.32 to $36.02, while bitcoin decreased from $8,331 to $8,321. This meant that the total profits that my short tips are making fell from $1,953 two weeks ago to $1,786 now. Still, at least all five of my short tips are still in the black. As well as being forced to close my Ted Baker tip, I recommend closing the open position on Superdry since it is still losing money six months after I recommended it in April (Issue 943).

This means that henceforth the number of long and short tips will be equal at six each. This also means that my remaining tips are making a profit of £5,511, while the losses on my closed tips have gone up to £6,356.

Over the next few months I'm going to make it a rule to close any position that I've held for longer than a year, unless there are really exceptional circumstances.

The stockmarket generally responds better when the cuts have come after a series of hikes. LPL Financial found that after five of seven of these occasions, the market was higher six months later with an average return of 7.5% (equivalent to an annualised return of 15.6%). However, it's important to note that in the two most recent cases, in 2001 and 2007, following this theory would have lost you money as the stockmarket was down by 9.5% and 14.6% respectively six months after the Fed started cutting.

Recommended

How to invest in the chipmakers fixing the semiconductor shortage
Share tips

How to invest in the chipmakers fixing the semiconductor shortage

Last year’s chip crunch brought home how dependent the world is on these tiny pieces of silicon. Chipmakers are rushing to build new factories. Will t…
28 Jan 2022
Share tips of the week – 28 January
Share tips

Share tips of the week – 28 January

MoneyWeek’s comprehensive guide to the best of this week’s share tips from the rest of the UK's financial pages.
28 Jan 2022
Energy stocks will only get better in 2022 – here are three to buy
Share tips

Energy stocks will only get better in 2022 – here are three to buy

Professional investor Jonathan Waghorn of Guinness Global Investors picks three top energy stocks.
28 Jan 2022
How to invest in blockchain without buying cryptocurrencies
Bitcoin & crypto

How to invest in blockchain without buying cryptocurrencies

Many investors have been searching for a way to invest in bitcoin in their Sipp or Isa via a regular broker account. This fund fits the bill nicely, s…
27 Jan 2022

Most Popular

Shareholder capitalism: why we must return power to listed companies’ ultimate owners
Investment strategy

Shareholder capitalism: why we must return power to listed companies’ ultimate owners

Under our system of shareholder capitalism it's not fund managers, it‘s the individual investors – the company's ultimate owners – who should be telli…
24 Jan 2022
Amazon halts plans to ban UK Visa credit card payments
Personal finance

Amazon halts plans to ban UK Visa credit card payments

Amazon has said that it is to shelve its proposed ban on UK customers making payments with Visa credit cards.
17 Jan 2022
Temple Bar’s Ian Lance and Nick Purves: the essence of value investing
Investment strategy

Temple Bar’s Ian Lance and Nick Purves: the essence of value investing

Ian Lance and Nick Purves of the Temple Bar investment trust explain the essence of “value investing” – buying something for less than its intrinsic v…
14 Jan 2022