Three investments to own in our debt-soaked world

There is too much debt in the world, says Tim Price, and not all of it will get paid back. With that in mind, here's how he's investing now.

A man enters the Tokyo Stock Exchange © Kiyoshi Ota/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Japan looks spectacularly cheap

A man enters the Tokyo Stock Exchange © Kiyoshi Ota/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Editor's note: this morning we have a guest post from Tim Price, acclaimed value fund manager and regular MoneyWeek contributor.

"The problem is not so much to see what nobody has yet seen, as to think what nobody has yet thought concerning that which everybody sees." Arthur Schopenhauer.

Inasmuch as we pay any homage to macro-economics, our investment thesis is straightforward: there is too much debt in the world, and not all of it will get paid back.

As something of a film buff, I am fond of citing the 1983 Cold War film War Games in defence of this investment approach: if you don't understand the rules of the game, sometimes it's better not to play.

Why Japan looks spectacularly cheap

No doubt certain traders think they understand why it makes sense to own debt issued by insolvent governments at negative yields (duh! QE!), but we're in the business of capital preservation as opposed to speculating in return-free risk at its all-time highs.

As financial analyst and market historian Russell Napier points out in his Solid Ground newsletter of 19 June ("The jolt of the needle: record low bond yields and the earthquake that follows"), many key government bond yields have fallen below both their 2009 and 2016 lows.

As Napier observes: "As a financial analyst, one is often asked, Where do you see financial bubbles today?' When risk-free rates are this low, it is easy to see them everywhere, but of course the biggest bubble must be in those so-called risk free rates' themselves. Remember these are the risk-free' assets many financial institutions are forced to hold to reduce their balance sheet risk!"

So, absent a modest allocation to near-cash short term government debt, and only the most objectively creditworthy and inflation-linked corporate debt, bonds are basically out.

That isn't necessarily a problem, though, as it still leaves us with a massive investment opportunity set, incorporating value stocks from around the world, systematic trend-following funds, and real assets, notably the monetary metals. (Our best attempt, to date, to solve the riddle of owning a variety of sensible assets that are also uncorrelated against each other.)

For anyone owning listed stocks, at the risk of sounding like a broken record, the really compelling value is still on offer in Japan. As CLSA's John Seagrim points out, Japanese stocks (as measured by the Topix index) are far cheaper in terms of tangible book value (trading on around 1.4 times) than either the S&P 500 (at more than 11 times), or the MSCI Europe (just above four times).

Yet strip out financials, and Japan moves from being spectacularly cheap to being unbelievably, mind-alteringly cheap. Exclude financials, and against tangible book value, the US trades on 37.1 times tangible book value and Japan trades at 1.67 times. (You can perhaps see why we have more exposure to Japan in our fund than any other market.)

Why I like trend-following funds and gold

Systematic trend-followers (put simply, funds which aim to profit from momentum investing) have admittedly been sub-par performers for some time. But we like the risk/reward.

The risk is that we incur perhaps a few years of relatively modest losses. The reward is that we own vehicles that are genuinely uncorrelated to stock and bond markets and which offer the potential to generate outsized gains as and when substantial price trends emerge (not least on the downside).

Which brings us to "real" assets. If you believe, as we do, that the endgame of this absurd monetary experiment will be a messily inflationary one (albeit perhaps with a dash of deflationary black comedy before we get there), then it makes sense to own an inflation hedge. Perhaps a store of value that has remained such for 5,000 years.

As the good folk at Incrementum point out in their magisterial assessment of prospects for gold, In Gold We Trust, it turns out that gold hasn't been a bad store of value even over the last extraordinary two decades of widespread financial fraud and currency and interest rate debauchery.

And as Incrementum suggests: "The past 12 months have shown that the seemingly invulnerable economic upswing has begun to crack deeply. The worldwide boom, driven by low interest rates and a ceaseless expansion of credit and money, now stands on feet of clay. The probability that the boom will turn to a bust is high, or at least significantly higher than the mainstream assumes.

"The developing political, social, economic, and technological upheavals are enormous. On many fronts confidence in the existing order is crumbling, while the new order has not yet gained enough trust to have a stabilizing effect. This trend will intensify in the coming years.

"In addition, the bubbles in the equity, bond, and real estate markets the Everything Bubble and the corrosive dynamic of over-indebtedness further exacerbate the fragility of markets month after month, week after week, day after day."

As we've remarked, we don't really do macro. Instead, we try and move client capital away from the more obvious red flags and towards the more obvious opportunities displaying high quality, and/or a lack of correlation to traditional markets, and/or otherwise defensive characteristics. Value stocks; trend-followers; gold. So what colour is your parachute?

Tim Price is co-manager of the VT Price Value Portfolio and author of Investing through the Looking Glass: a rational guide to irrational financial markets.

Recommended

How to invest in ChatGPT and other AI tech changing the world
Tech stocks

How to invest in ChatGPT and other AI tech changing the world

Technology, like ChatGPT, is changing the way we live and work, and this new tool could have a huge impact on the tech industry says Dominic Frisby.
23 Jan 2023
Active investing vs passive investing: which is best?
Investment strategy

Active investing vs passive investing: which is best?

Active investing strategies didn’t do well in 2023 as passive investing continued to draw in new assets.
20 Jan 2023
Key dates for 2023: here are the dates you need to know when it comes to your money
Personal finance

Key dates for 2023: here are the dates you need to know when it comes to your money

There is no shortage of important dates to be aware of this year – which are likely to affect your financial health. We run through the key dates in 2…
4 Jan 2023
Investing trends to watch out for in 2023: what analysts say
Investment strategy

Investing trends to watch out for in 2023: what analysts say

What are sensible strategies for high inflationary times? We ask analysts to find out.
22 Dec 2022

Most Popular

Top 10 areas most immune to a house price crash
House prices

Top 10 areas most immune to a house price crash

New research pinpoints the towns, cities and London boroughs most insulated from house price falls this year - and which are the most exposed.
31 Jan 2023
When will interest rates go up?
UK Economy

When will interest rates go up?

New interest rates will be announced on 2 February – we look at what to expect.
1 Feb 2023
Top 10 up and coming property areas in the UK
Property

Top 10 up and coming property areas in the UK

New research shows rural areas make for the best investment, while London boroughs dominated the bottom 10
31 Jan 2023