Is there a case for higher fund management fees?

Some private-equity and hedge funds are trying it on and raising their already high fund management fees. Investors should not be fooled.

944_MW_P16_City-View

Human fund managers can't afford to rest on their laurels

Andrew Bret Wallis

The fund industry, despite its seeming simplicity, has never been a low-cost one. And right now, a section of it seems to be getting more expensive than ever. In private equity, what is known as the "carried interest" for the partners in the fund has traditionally been 20%. In simple terms, they get a fifth of any profits the fund makes on its investments. They usually charge 2% of the funds under management as well to cover basic costs. In the last year, however, a group of leading private-equity funds, including big names such as Carlyle and Bain Capital, have raised the share of profits that go to the partners from 20% to 30%.

The hedgies make their move

It is easy enough to understand why they are tempted. After all, there is no easier way to raise profits than to put up prices. A $1bn hedge or private-equity fund has a fixed level of costs to cover staff, administration, marketing and compliance, but it doesn't make much difference to those whetherthe fees are "one and ten" or "four and 40".

But it makes a huge difference to profits. The extra income drops on to the bottom lines.

Customers might even put up with the increase. The funds putting up their fees argue that they are charging a little more for exceptional performance. If you have money in a fund that is regularly delivering 20% or 30% a year, then maybe you don't mind if a third of those profits go to the managers. After all, if you take it out you might end up in a fund that makes only 5%, and that would leave you a lot worse off. And it certainly means they will have plenty of incentive to make a lot of money and you will benefit from that. Even so, it is still a mistake. Why? There are two reasons.

Why funds should be cheaper

Next, artificial intelligence (AI). There are plenty of robo-funds that can pick investments, often just as well as thepin-striped alternative. It might be a while before an AI program can run a private-equity fund. But many hedge funds can be run by computers for virtually nothing.And the more they charge, the more incentive there is for smart entrepreneurs to design AI programs that can replace them.

Funds should therefore be cheaper to run, and savings should be passed on to customers. Indeed, perhaps the reason fees are edging up among established fund managers is precisely because lower-cost rivals are starting to nibble away at their market and so they are charging those customers who remain more. But the more expensive they get, the more space they open up for rivals to undercut them.

The real challenge for the City is to work out how to offer a cheaper, better service, at lower cost. A few hedge and private-equity funds might get away with higher fees for a while, and a tiny handful might have the performance to justify it over the medium term. But for most of them, it will ultimately prove fatal and will simply drive investors to lower cost alternatives.

Recommended

Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust update: share price down as tech stocks crash
Investment trusts

Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust update: share price down as tech stocks crash

Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust has been remarkably successful over the years but is now trading at a discount to its NAV due to falling tech stock…
28 Jan 2022
How to invest in blockchain without buying cryptocurrencies
Bitcoin & crypto

How to invest in blockchain without buying cryptocurrencies

Many investors have been searching for a way to invest in bitcoin in their Sipp or Isa via a regular broker account. This fund fits the bill nicely, s…
27 Jan 2022
A cheap investment trust with a good record
Investment trusts

A cheap investment trust with a good record

This cheap investment trust’s yield of almost 9% may look too good to be true, but should be sustainable, says Max King.
25 Jan 2022
Invest in VCTs: tax-free investments set to break records
Investment strategy

Invest in VCTs: tax-free investments set to break records

Generous tax breaks make VCTs – venture capital funds – an attractive supplement to pensions.
21 Jan 2022

Most Popular

Shareholder capitalism: why we must return power to listed companies’ ultimate owners
Investment strategy

Shareholder capitalism: why we must return power to listed companies’ ultimate owners

Under our system of shareholder capitalism it's not fund managers, it‘s the individual investors – the company's ultimate owners – who should be telli…
24 Jan 2022
Amazon halts plans to ban UK Visa credit card payments
Personal finance

Amazon halts plans to ban UK Visa credit card payments

Amazon has said that it is to shelve its proposed ban on UK customers making payments with Visa credit cards.
17 Jan 2022
Temple Bar’s Ian Lance and Nick Purves: the essence of value investing
Investment strategy

Temple Bar’s Ian Lance and Nick Purves: the essence of value investing

Ian Lance and Nick Purves of the Temple Bar investment trust explain the essence of “value investing” – buying something for less than its intrinsic v…
14 Jan 2022