What Breaking Bad teaches you about smart-beta funds
Matthew Partridge looks at what lessons television drama Breaking Bad holds for investors.
Breaking Bad is a TV series that ran for five series from January 2008 to September 2013. It charts the life of Walter White, a mild-mannered chemistry teacher whose world is turned upside down when he is diagnosed with lung cancer.
In an effort to cover the cost of treatment and secure his family's financial future, he joins forces with former pupil and small-time drug dealer Jesse Pinkman to manufacture methamphetamine. Over time, White becomes a ruthless drug lord, teaming up with drug cartels to expand his market.
The key moment
Early on, White attempts to make meth for the first time in a camper van he has bought for the purpose. Initially, Pinkman scoffs at his partner's insistence on using proper procedures, with precise measurements and proper equipment, favouring a more "artistic" approach.
MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
Sign up to Money Morning
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don't miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
At the insistence of his former teacher, Pinkman reluctantly follows the instructions. When he samples the final product, Pinkman is amazed at its quality and exclaims "This is this is art, Mr White!" "Actually, it's just basic chemistry," White retorts.
Lessons for investors
Just like White, some in the fund-management industry aim to apply basic science to improve its products. Their "smart-beta" funds aim to beat the market, just as active fund managers do.
However, they eschew the art of stockpicking in favour of a scientific approach that combines the low cost of passively tracking stock indices with stock-picking strategies that have been shown in academic studies consistently to beat the market, such as value investing. Because smart-beta funds automatically follow set criteria, they eliminate the need for a human manager. This should keep fees low and eliminate human biases.
There are three types of smart-beta fund. One group aims to replicate a market index, but in a slightly different way from the traditional method of weighting by market capitalisation. For instance, they might allocate shares in their portfolio according to earnings or dividends.
A more "active" group only buys stocks that perform best against certain criteria. Some funds go further by screening and ranking stocks by multiple criteria. However, the more elaborate the approach, the higher the fees, and the lower the cost advantage. Whether such strategies will make investors as stinking rich as Walter White became remains to be seen.
Get the latest financial news, insights and expert analysis from our award-winning MoneyWeek team, to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

-
Steve Webb: The triple lock is there to do a job. I’m not embarrassed or ashamed of itThe triple lock means 13 million pensioners will now get an above-inflation state pension boost in April. While the rising cost of the policy has stirred controversy, Steve Webb, who served as pensions minister when it was introduced, argues the triple lock is vital and should stay. Webb speaks to Kalpana Fitzpatrick on the new episode of MoneyWeek Talks – out now.
-
How retirement pots risk running out 11 years early if inflation remains highPension savers could find their retirement income may not last as long as they anticipated over fears that inflation may not slow down