Book of the week: a country with coherent vision for its future

Book review: Russia Without Putin Tony Wood argues that the contemporary Western view of Russia lacks subtlety.

926-books-Russia-Without-Putin

Money, Power and the Mythsof the New Cold WarBy Tony WoodVerso Books (£20)Buy on Amazon

Former US secretary of state Dean Acheson said in 1962 that Britain had lost an empire and "not yet found a role". Tony Wood argues that the same applies to modern Russia. His thesis is that the contemporary view of Russia as dominated by a group of tightly knit oligarchs trying to recreate the Soviet Union lacks subtlety. The truth is that Russia has no coherent vision for its future.

Wood argues that, until the invasion of Georgia in 2008, Russia was willing to become part of the international system, and was even open to working with the US against terrorism. Indeed, Putin was initially praised for his pro-market economic reforms (with The New York Times's columnist Tom Friedman notoriously advising readers to "keep rootin' for Putin"). However, Russia's moves towards co-operation were met with rejection by a US that saw these concessions as a sign of weakness. By expanding Nato to Russia's borders, and withdrawing from the anti-ballistic missile treaty in 2002, America essentially withdrew any incentive for Russia to behave as a responsible member of the global community.

Wood also contends that the relationship between business and power in post-Soviet Russia is a bit more complex than the popular perception of a "mafia state" and needs to be understood in the context of the rapid economic "shock therapy" of the early 1990s, when the economy was opened up to market forces. The oligarchs who seized control of assets in that period are not a homogenous bunch there is a division between the former managers of industrial firms and the officials who used their influence to take control of resource-based companies. The reforms caused a huge amount of disruption to the lives of ordinary people, especially those who had depended on the state for a living.

This is true, but by blaming the West for the breakdown in relations, Wood ignores the fact that other countries, notably West Germany and Japan afterWorld War II, managed to turn their energies towards productive, not destructive, activities in the wake of military defeat. It is also true the West could have provided more economic support for Russia's transition to a market economy, but the problem is that Russia has clung to the idea that the Soviet Union's demise was a voluntary act by Mikhail Gorbachev, rather than the inevitable (and necessary) implosion of an unsustainable system.

Those interested in the wider context of Russian economic and foreign policy will enjoy this book. However, Wood allows the detail to obscure the wider reality. He is also a bit too sympathetic to Putin and the system in which he operates.

Recommended

My must-read of 2020: a page-turning biography of Keynes
Investment strategy

My must-read of 2020: a page-turning biography of Keynes

John Stepek recommends some of his favourite financial books for you to read as lockdowns continue, including a surprisingly gripping biography of the…
31 Dec 2020
Five books to put on your Christmas list
Investment strategy

Five books to put on your Christmas list

Even if they’ve done nothing else, lockdowns – in whatever guise – have given us plenty of time to read. Merryn Somerset Webb picks five books to enjo…
7 Dec 2020

Most Popular

Why the UK's 2.5% inflation is a big deal
Inflation

Why the UK's 2.5% inflation is a big deal

After years of inflation being a financial-assets problem, it is now an “ordinary things” problem too, says Merryn Somerset Webb. But central banks st…
16 Jul 2021
The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism
Economy

The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism

Russell Napier talks to Merryn about financial repression – or "stealing money from old people slowly" – plus how Asian capitalism is taking over in t…
16 Jul 2021
Cryptocurrency roundup: Twitter founder’s “DeFi” platform
Bitcoin & crypto

Cryptocurrency roundup: Twitter founder’s “DeFi” platform

In crypto this week: regulators are getting worried; Jack Dorsey’s bitcoin DeFi platform; and dogecoin’s co-founder lambasts cryptocurrencies.  Salon…
16 Jul 2021