Why you can’t rely on markets to tell you anything useful

The market reaction to Donald Trump’s threat of a trade war has been muted to say the least. But that doesn’t mean anything, says John Stepek. Here’s why.

Trump: wants to impose tariffs in "a loving way".

2018 Anadolu Agency

Donald Trump is thinking of starting a global trade war.

He also said something the other day about imposing tariffs in "a loving way". Which, however you look at it, is just weird.

Meanwhile, Gary Cohn seen as one of the few "adults" in the White House, even by those who don't like him has walked out, mainly because he couldn't convince the US president not to start a trade war.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Yet the market doesn't seem bothered.

Does it know something we don't? Should we listen to the wisdom of the crowd when it tells us not to worry?

I think you can guess my take on that.

Why the market has a tendency to run off the edge of a cliff

We'll get back to Trump and his loving tariffs in a second. First, let's examine the market reaction.

Cohn walked out on Tuesday. He's an ex-Goldman Sachs guy, so Wall Street liked him; he was one of them. On a wider basis, he was also seen as someone who had a grip on reality and also something approximating a backbone in terms of having a set of coherent beliefs that wouldn't simply flip-flop with Trump's whims.

The market didn't like it at first. Particularly as, for a brief period, it thought that Cohn had managed to talk Trump out of imposing any tariffs. But it rebounded yesterday, and now it's as though nothing's changed.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

So what's it all about? For that, we have to turn to one of the many "flaws" we see in markets the fact that momentum investing works.

Momentum investing is one of several "factors" that are recognised as exceptions to the "efficient markets" rule.

Factors are anomalies that allow you to beat the market over time. In effect, they wouldn't work if human beings acted in the narrowly rational way in which theory assumes we act.

The way momentum investing works is simple in theory: you buy what keeps going up and you sell what keeps going down. (It's harder in practice, like all of these "factors", but we're just dealing with the theory today so we'll put that aside for now.)

So why does momentum investing work? Why, once a stock or a market is on a rising trajectory, is it more likely to keep rising?

Or, to bring it down to what's going on today, specifically why is the market so willing to shrug off what seems like pretty bad news in favour of sticking with the status quo?

Advertisement - Article continues below

Put simply, it's because we have selective hearing.

A mob of lazy coyotes

We don't like to change our minds. Once we find a worldview that we're comfortable with, and one that seems to work pretty well, we're loath to move away from it. So our brains immunise themselves against contradictory data and attend to stories that confirm what we already believe ("confirmation bias").

There are all sorts of reasons for this. If you find a way of looking at the world that works, then ditching it for a new worldview is risky. A disinclination to change your mind also prevents terminal analysis paralysis if you didn't have a "default" setting, then it would be hard to get anything done at all. And there's all sorts of tribal stuff too.

Advertisement - Article continues below

But you don't need to get deep into the weeds on the psychology to understand this. Put very simply: we're lazy. Changing your mind takes cognitive effort; it's hard. Most of the time, we don't like expending effort unless we need to.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Hence, we like to assume that things are going to stay the same as they were yesterday. Hence, momentum investing works, because it's based on extrapolation, which is among the most basic forms of pattern-spotting behaviour in human beings.

Problem is, no trend lasts forever. Momentum might take you over the edge of the cliff, and like Wile E Coyote on the roadrunner cartoons, you might even keep running on thin air for a while.

But eventually you realise something's changed. And from that point, it's a long way down.

Maybe it'll all be fine

Don't get me wrong maybe we'll get lucky. I can't follow Trump's decision-making process, but he does seem to flit about a lot, playing favourites. Keeping his court on their toes.

He seems to be backing away from his original idea of just slapping on steel and aluminium tariffs willy-nilly, and moving towards something that's more specifically targeted at China. We'll see when he actually signs off on the tariff policy.

Advertisement - Article continues below

And making short-term bets on political manoeuvring is a good way to lose money in any case.

But while I think we can't ignore the wider move towards de-globalisation and other inflationary policies, that's not really my point this morning. My point is more this: don't imagine that the market can tell you anything useful about all of this.

It's easy to assume that the market knows best. That the absence of a huge reaction to apparently bad news means that you must have misunderstood what's going on.

Momentum and confirmation bias mean that once the market has got a certain idea in its head, it's very hard to shake it off. And that tendency gets more pronounced the longer the trend goes on for.

At the bottom of a market no one wants to buy because they assume it'll keep going down. At the top of a market, no one wants to sell because they assume it'll keep going up.

All that you can do as an individual investor is to ignore the direction and to look at the value on offer. Right now, US stocks might be going up, but they look very expensive, regardless of what Trump pulls out of his hat next. That's reason enough to have most of your money elsewhere.




How long can the good times roll?

Despite all the doom and gloom that has dominated our headlines for most of 2019, Britain and most of the rest of the developing world is currently en…
19 Dec 2019

The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019

There are lots of reasons to be bearish – but you should stick with the bulls

There are plenty of reasons to be gloomy about the stockmarkets. But the trend remains up, says Dominic Frisby. And you don’t want to bet against the …
17 Jul 2019

Good news on jobs scares US stockmarkets

June brought the best monthly US jobs growth of the year, but stockmarkets were not best pleased.
11 Jul 2019

Most Popular

Industrial metals

Governments’ money-printing mania bodes well for base metals

Money is being printed like there is no tomorrow. Much of it will be used to pay for infrastructure projects – and that will be good for metals, says …
27 May 2020
EU Economy

Here’s why investors should care about the EU’s plan to tackle Covid-19

The EU's €750bn rescue package makes a break-up of the eurozone much less likely. John Stepek explains why the scheme is such a big deal, and what it …
28 May 2020

In support of active fund management

We’re fans of passive investing here at MoneyWeek. But active fund management has its place too, says Merryn Somerset Webb.
25 May 2020