Advertisement

Ignore the Cape sceptics

The cyclically adjusted price-earnings (Cape) ratio is an excellent predictor of long-term equity returns. And now, in the US at least, it is flashing red.

878_Markets

The cyclically adjusted price-earnings (Cape) ratio is an excellent predictor of long-term equity returns, not only in the US, but also across the world, say Rob Arnott, Vitali Kalesnik and Jim Masturzo in a note for Research Affiliates. It takes into account earnings over ten years, thus smoothing out the ups and downs of the business cycle. The higher the Cape the more expensive your starting valuation the lower your long-term returns. Today the US Cape is flashing red. It's reached 32, a level surpassed only during the bubble of 1929 and the technology bubble in the late 1990s. The long-term average since the 1880s is around 17.

Excuses, excuses

Whenever the Cape is high, strategists come up with all sorts of explanations for why a higher Cape is potentially justified, and thus perhaps not necessarily a sign of poor long-term returns. Cape sceptics point out that the measure has been unusually elevated since the turn of the century, averaging about 26. One argument is that there has been a structural change in corporate profitability, justifying a higher Cape.

Advertisement - Article continues below

An increase in profit margins and the share of corporate profits to GDP have been notable features of the past decade or so. Globalisation has given US corporations a boost, trade-union power has receded, while lower interest and higher leverage have juiced earnings. The past two decades have also seen a decline in macroeconomic volatility, thus justifying an equilibrium Cape of 23.

Neither of these ideas are terribly convincing, says Research Affiliates. It's far from clear that profits have reached a permanently higher plateau, justifying a higher Cape. Profit margins and earnings as a share of GDP revert to the mean. "We are sceptical that earnings can grow much in the years ahead, relative to GDP, without causing a populist backlash", especially given years of stagnant real wages. Also note that real S&P 500 earnings peaked in 2014, so the earnings upswing may already be over.

Expensive on any score

Even if lower volatility is permanent, it does not justify a Cape of 32. And markets outside the US are nowhere near US levels. The sceptics also ignore the fact that a shrinking workforce, implying slower profit growth, is an argument for a lower equilibrium Cape. "Those offering eulogies for the Cape ratio are premature as has been the case repeatedly in the past."

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

The British equity market is shrinking
Stockmarkets

The British equity market is shrinking

British startups are abandoning public stockmarkets and turning to deep-pocketed Silicon Valley venture capitalists for their investment needs.
8 Nov 2019
BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it
Income investing

BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it

BP has bowed to the inevitable and cut its dividend in half – and its share price promptly rose. John Stepek explains what it means for shareholders …
4 Aug 2020
Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences
Stockmarkets

Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences

Private equity is taking over from public stockmarkets as the biggest provider of capital to companies. That’s bad for investors and bad for society a…
3 Aug 2020
The revolutionary potential of 5G
Sponsored

The revolutionary potential of 5G

SPONSORED CONTENT – With the right investment and support, the next generation of connectivity could transform society
3 Aug 2020

Most Popular

BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it
Income investing

BP has slashed its dividend – and markets love it

BP has bowed to the inevitable and cut its dividend in half – and its share price promptly rose. John Stepek explains what it means for shareholders …
4 Aug 2020
Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences
Stockmarkets

Listed companies are dying out, and that could have serious consequences

Private equity is taking over from public stockmarkets as the biggest provider of capital to companies. That’s bad for investors and bad for society a…
3 Aug 2020
Can the recent rally in sterling continue?
Sponsored

Can the recent rally in sterling continue?

A "double top"  – a very recognisable pattern – is forming in in the US dollar. Dominic Frisby explains what it is, and what it could tell us about st…
3 Aug 2020