Until this week, the Shanghai Composite index had rallied for three weeks in a row. Investors were starting to think that the government had managed to stabilise the market after doing practically everything to prop stocks up. It loosened monetary policy, stopped flotations and share sales by major stockholders, banned short selling, and bought stocks.
But last Monday the market fell by 8.5%, its worst day since early 2007, and second-worst percentage drop ever. The next day it fell marginally, as state-directed investors piled in again.
It looks as though the government took its foot off the accelerator on Monday, reducing capital inflows after its recent "frenzied" efforts, says Nigel Green of deVere Group and gravity promptly took over. The government's arsenal isn't exhausted yet, says John Foley on breakingviews.com.
Subscribe to MoneyWeek
Subscribe to MoneyWeek today and get your first six magazine issues absolutely FREE
It could cut interest rates again, or insist that state-owned companies buy back their shares, for instance. "But short of announcing an open-ended direct purchase of shares in the market, all options are likely to have diminishing returns."
Beijing now faces "an unenviable choice", as the Financial Times points out: sink even more into its campaign to stop allowing stocks to settle at their natural level, "or let slip its mask of invulnerability". The market could be in for a rocky ride either way.
Bullishness will dwindle if the government keeps acting but seems unable to bolster stocks, but if it now steps away there will be further falls as people fear there is no safety net at all. The state has forfeited credibility and could dent confidence by having to "concede a clear limit to its powers", says the FT.
Along with the commodities slump and the junk bond jitters, China's slump is a worry for investors. However, it looks far more containable than the other two. As Roger Bootle of Capital Economics notes, China's stockmarket is worth just 30% of GDP, compared to over 100% in most countries. One in 30 Chinese owns shares, compared to one in seven Americans.
Also, the market is still up by 66% on a year ago, so a downward wealth effect is unlikely. "Nor is the equity market important as a channel for companies to raise finance." Some brokerages may go bust, given the margin debt in the market, but overall the potential impact on China's economy, and global growth, looks limited.
Sign up for MoneyWeek's newsletters
Get the latest financial news, insights and expert analysis from our award-winning MoneyWeek team, to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Andrew is the editor of MoneyWeek magazine. He grew up in Vienna and studied at the University of St Andrews, where he gained a first-class MA in geography & international relations.
After graduating he began to contribute to the foreign page of The Week and soon afterwards joined MoneyWeek at its inception in October 2000. He helped Merryn Somerset Webb establish it as Britain’s best-selling financial magazine, contributing to every section of the publication and specialising in macroeconomics and stockmarkets, before going part-time.
His freelance projects have included a 2009 relaunch of The Pharma Letter, where he covered corporate news and political developments in the German pharmaceuticals market for two years, and a multiyear stint as deputy editor of the Barclays account at Redwood, a marketing agency.
Andrew has been editing MoneyWeek since 2018, and continues to specialise in investment and news in German-speaking countries owing to his fluent command of the language.
Nationwide: House prices see biggest monthly fall in over two years
Portfolio landlords could save £8,500 by remortgaging – or risk costs soaring by £23,000
