China: no great leap forward

China-watchers were left disappointed after the leadership failed to make plans to liberalise the economy.

China's Third Plenum, a four-day gathering designed to chart China's direction for the next decade, ended this week. A similar meeting in 1978 set China on the path towards the free market.

This time observers were hoping for a clear sign of the extent to which China intends to liberalise its economy now that the new Communist Party leaders are stamping their authority on the government. They didn't get one.

What the commentators said

Bloomberg, for instance, noted that the 5,000 character statement alluded to reform' 59 times; socialism' 28 times but finance' just once.

"Mavens [mulling the paper] over their macchiatos" will have noted that it said markets would henceforth be made decisive' in allocating resources, a step up from their basic' role of old. Then again, the economic role of the state is described as dominant'.

Nor is there a sense from this vague document of how the various changes mentioned fit together, said Capital Economics. "Without a clearly articulated vision to guide officials at all levels of government, we suspect that reformers will struggle to push piecemeal efforts against the opposition of vested interests."

Yet, without a bigger role for the market and hence private-sector activity in the next few years, China won't graduate from middle-income country to rich one, as Ian King pointed out in The Times.

Productivity and growth aren't going to rise significantly if state-owned industries continue to dominate, especially with the labour force now shrinking. Forget about the plenum communiqu, concluded John Foley on Breakingviews, and just focus on what China actually does in the near future.

The acid test is whether it lets a struggling state-owned enterprise fail and be taken over, which would be "contrary to everything socialist leaders hold dear".

Recommended

The crisis brewing in emerging markets
Emerging markets

The crisis brewing in emerging markets

Covid-related political unrest and financial collapse in the developing world are the biggest threats right now, says Matthew Lynn.
25 Jul 2021
A new revolution in Cuba?
Economy

A new revolution in Cuba?

The biggest protests in decades have rocked the one-party communist state. But is change for the better really on the cards?
24 Jul 2021
Can Latin America's economies recover from the pandemic?
Emerging markets

Can Latin America's economies recover from the pandemic?

Few places have suffered as much from the Covid-19 pandemic as Latin America. A sustained commodity rally could help.  
23 Jul 2021
The five best ways to invest in India's promising future
Emerging markets

The five best ways to invest in India's promising future

The pandemic has been catastrophic for India, yet the stockmarket is hitting record highs. Investors are right to remain optimistic about the long ter…
23 Jul 2021

Most Popular

Why the UK's 2.5% inflation is a big deal
Inflation

Why the UK's 2.5% inflation is a big deal

After years of inflation being a financial-assets problem, it is now an “ordinary things” problem too, says Merryn Somerset Webb. But central banks st…
16 Jul 2021
The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism
Economy

The MoneyWeek Podcast: Asia, financial repression and the nature of capitalism

Russell Napier talks to Merryn about financial repression – or "stealing money from old people slowly" – plus how Asian capitalism is taking over in t…
16 Jul 2021
Cryptocurrency roundup: Twitter founder’s “DeFi” platform
Bitcoin & crypto

Cryptocurrency roundup: Twitter founder’s “DeFi” platform

In crypto this week: regulators are getting worried; Jack Dorsey’s bitcoin DeFi platform; and dogecoin’s co-founder lambasts cryptocurrencies.  Salon…
16 Jul 2021