Asian specialist Hugh Young of Aberdeen Asset Management tells Jody Clarke how to bet on the Asian consumer.
What is the most compelling investment in Asia right now?
There isn't anything terribly compelling after the rise in markets. So we're a little cautious on the whole. Currently, the cheapest things in Asia, in pure valuation terms, are Japanese small caps. You can find companies selling at 25p in the pound. But the trouble with Japan is that they have been cheap for ages and the management don't seem to be determined to do anything about it. So it comes with a big caveat. Thus if you want to know what's cheapest, that's what it would be things like Japanese property companies. But they come with high risk. If they were in America, they'd be taken over tomorrow. But Japan is not the US.
Try 6 free issues of MoneyWeek today
Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.
Start your trial
Sign up for MoneyWeek’s free twice-daily newsletter.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Are you a China sceptic?
Latest Videos FromMoneyWeek
Yes. Even before the markets went up and China looked a bit bubbly, we would have been more in the sceptics' camp. Our process is all to do with identifying high-quality companies and obviously buying at the right prices.
From our point of view, there are a lot of companies in China who are new to the stockmarket. Most have been spun out of state organisations. We are still unsure as to whether they will look after all their shareholders, or just the government, which is still the controlling shareholder.
We concentrate strongly on good-quality, honest, transparent companies. We reject a lot of politically connected companies because you eventually have to pay the piper. In Indonesia, for example, when everyone was buying into firms run by the Suharto family, we never touched them. So we feel a lot more comfortable playing China via Hong Kong. If you look at our positions, they are almost a mirror image of the benchmark. The benchmark has a big chunk in China and a small amount in Hong Kong, while we have a small amount in China and a large amount in Hong Kong.
Asian markets rose by more than 70% in 2009. Can investors still lock in higher returns by plumping for emerging markets?
Yes, providing they are careful. One of the problems you find where there is big growth is that people get distracted by headlines: "China growing by 10%, give us all your money." So they give it to someone in China and that's the last they see of it. The growth stories of the Chinas and Brazils are true, but you have to be cynical before parting with your money. Of course, that's true whether you are in England or China, but people often do some very thoughtless things with their money.
[Asian] stocks are on 18-times this year's earnings, so they are not dramatically overvalued. But there is a lot of good news in the price. On any decent time horizon, we're still fine. There are great companies with great prospects. But I'm cautious. Maybe it's to do with my age, but this year, who knows, the markets could easily be down 20% or 30%.
What's the best way to play the rise of the Asian consumer?
A very simple suggestion is to go for a stock called Dairy Farm (Singapore: DFI; LSE: DFIB). Its management is in Hong Kong. It's a retailer with Sainsbury's-type operations, but it also has drug stores. It has quite a regional profile. It's not cheap, but it's a classic link into the domestic consumer.
When I first started looking at these markets, people thought 'buy the Samsungs', or whatever the stocks of the day were 20 years ago on the manufacturing side, because they were supplying developed markets. But from that comes the steady growth of consumers, local banks or supermarkets.
How Hugh Young became Asia's top fund manager
Hugh Young, now 51, started out as a politics student at Exeter. "I had no idea what a share was when I came out of university", says Young "such was the education system all those years ago." He eventually "fell into the City", finding work in the research department of a small stockbroking firm. "It was pre-Big Bang. So I was the research department."
But it's perhaps no surprise he ended up in finance. Brought up in Wimbledon, Young's father was an investment manager who retired in 1970 on "what he thought was a great pension of £550 a year. And then we had inflation so the poor guy was beggared. As a result, he was a saver and I am a bit more of a spender." Young joined Aberdeen in 1985, then in 1992 set up the group's Asia-Pacific headquarters in Singapore. He is now regarded as one of the best-performing, Asia-focused fund managers. His steady long-term view and low-turnover trading style has seen the Aberdeen Global Asia Pacific Equity Fund (tel:01224-425255) return 201% over the last ten years, against 120% for the benchmark.
Young now lives in Singapore, with his wife and family. "Singapore has changed tremendously in the 18 years since I've lived here, from being in a sense quite parochial to a point where it is a lot more modern [than England]. I don't think there was a wine bar when I first arrived. Now, thank goodness, it's littered with them."
