Merryn's Blog

Which is the mansion?

A mansion tax on high-end property is a terrible idea - particularly if it comes with whopping rises in stamp duty. What Britain needs is another form of tax altogether.

Here's a new party game for you. Let's call it 'Spot the Mansion'. You open the links below and look at the houses. Then (trying please not to look at the sales prices), you guess which the Lib Dems think is a mansion and which they think is an ordinary person's house.

Property oneProperty twoProperty three
Property fourProperty fiveProperty six
Property seven
Property eightProperty nine
Property ten

As you have probably guessed by now, all the odd numbers are mansions and all the evennumbers are not mansions (ie, the nice houses in which you might aspire to live,but are so expensive to keep up that you have to be rich to own them). It makes the idea of a mansion tax seem a bit silly, doesn't it?

That's particularly the case if you marry the idea of taxing apparently high-end property with whopping rises in stamp duty, as today's papers suggest is about to happen again with the data emerging from the London market at the moment.

In the third quarter of this year, transactions fell by 9% in prime central London to a mere 5,226. But look at Greater London, and in particular at the £2m-£5m sector, and you can see just how the effects of the new tax legislation are beginning to bite (these put stamp duty up to 7% for people and 15% for companies on property valued at over £2m). Transactions are down 53%.

Yes, you read that right. 53%. Regular readers will know that we aren't against changes to the property tax regime - we'd swap the lot for a location taxor for a capital gains charge on first homes. But we can't really see the good in going about it like this.

Stamp duty is a terrible tax for all the reasons I mention here, but the main problem with it is the way in which it freezes transactions and cripples labour mobility. We need less of it, not more of it.

PS -I can't write it all again, so as the whole idea of a wealth tax on property won't go away, here is my last blog on it: A wealth tax on the value of property is a bad idea. And the one before that: Will the wealth tax never die?

Recommended

How should we go about “levelling up” Britain?
UK Economy

How should we go about “levelling up” Britain?

“Levelling up”, long a mantra of Boris Johnson’s government, now has a minister and a department in charge of delivering it. But will they succeed?
4 Dec 2021
Forget socialism – shareholder capitalism is delivering
Economy

Forget socialism – shareholder capitalism is delivering

Many Millennials say they would prefer to live in a socialist society. That's understandable. But while socialism promises everyone ownership and powe…
3 Dec 2021
Bubbles grow in global property markets as house prices continue to rise
Property

Bubbles grow in global property markets as house prices continue to rise

House prices grew by 6% in the year to mid-2021 in 25 global cities, with the German property market in particular showing signs of overheating.
3 Dec 2021
In praise of capitalism, the noble path that leads to profits
Economy

In praise of capitalism, the noble path that leads to profits

Contrary to modern myth, profits are not always a result of greed, but a signal of virtue. Stuart Watkins reports.
3 Dec 2021

Most Popular

Don’t worry about the global population explosion – it’s unlikely to happen
Investment strategy

Don’t worry about the global population explosion – it’s unlikely to happen

One of the many things we are taught to worry about is the fast-rising global population. But in fact, says Merryn Somerset Webb, the opposite is tru…
15 Nov 2021
Four of the best new investment trust listings
Investment trusts

Four of the best new investment trust listings

Diversify your portfolio and benefit from rising dividends with these four new investment trusts coming to the market soon.
15 Nov 2021
Three safe bets on the growing online gambling sector
Share tips

Three safe bets on the growing online gambling sector

Professional investor Aaron Fischer, creator of the Fischer Sports Betting and iGaming ETF, picks three of his favourite online gambling stocks.
29 Nov 2021