Merryn's Blog

Spotting a ‘good’ charity is harder than it looks

The idea that ‘good’ charities spend less on administration than ‘bad’ charities is not necessarily true, says Merryn Somerset Webb. It’s much more complicated than that.

What makes a good charity? The obvious answer is the one you will hear most often: a good charity supports an excellent cause and spends more on that cause than on administering itself. But not everyone agrees that this is in any way true.

Caroline Fiennes, author of It Ain't What You Give, has long been working to convince us that most of the things most people think about the charitable sector are wildly wrong.

So, now that the Public Accounts Committee has started to mutter about limiting the amount that charities spend on administration, she wasted no time in forwarding to me the details of a study undertaken by Caroline's organisation, Giving Evidence, using data takenfrom GiveWell, a US non-profit organisation run by some ex Wall Street analysts.

Giving Evidence spent a substantial amount of time doing "some of the most rigorous and detailed charity analysis on Earth", with a view to finding the charities that can give donors the most bang for their buck.

Look at their 2011 reviews and recommendations. It turns out that their top tips spend on average 11.5% of their total funds on admin; those that Giving Evidence didn't feel confident recommending spent only 10.8%.

In 2009, the group produced four different rankings. Those rated gold' had admin costs of around 16%; those that were not rated at all came in at more like 9.5%.

This isn't the end of the debate on the subject. Maybe all charities would be better if they were never allowed to spend more than 7%. Or maybe not. But what it does show very clearly is that spending slightly more than average on admin is more likely to suggest that a charity is working hard to make sure that every pound it does spend is used effectively than that it isn't a good charity.

PS To show how spending on admin can work, here is an example from Giving Evidence:

"Chance UK provides mentors for primary school children who are at risk of developing anti-social behaviour and possibly being permanently excluded from school []

"The charity spent some money evaluating its work. It found that male mentors were best suited to children with behavioural difficulties, whereas children with emotional problems responded best to female mentors The money spent on that evaluation would normally count as admin', but for the children receiving support which has improved because of that insight, it was money well spent."

Recommended

How should we go about “levelling up” Britain?
UK Economy

How should we go about “levelling up” Britain?

“Levelling up”, long a mantra of Boris Johnson’s government, now has a minister and a department in charge of delivering it. But will they succeed?
4 Dec 2021
Forget socialism – shareholder capitalism is delivering
Economy

Forget socialism – shareholder capitalism is delivering

Many Millennials say they would prefer to live in a socialist society. That's understandable. But while socialism promises everyone ownership and powe…
3 Dec 2021
In praise of capitalism, the noble path that leads to profits
Economy

In praise of capitalism, the noble path that leads to profits

Contrary to modern myth, profits are not always a result of greed, but a signal of virtue. Stuart Watkins reports.
3 Dec 2021
It’s official – inflation is no longer transitory
Inflation

It’s official – inflation is no longer transitory

America’s central bank has had a change of heart on inflation, and wants to retire the word “transitory”. John Stepek explains what that means for mar…
1 Dec 2021

Most Popular

Don’t worry about the global population explosion – it’s unlikely to happen
Investment strategy

Don’t worry about the global population explosion – it’s unlikely to happen

One of the many things we are taught to worry about is the fast-rising global population. But in fact, says Merryn Somerset Webb, the opposite is tru…
15 Nov 2021
Four of the best new investment trust listings
Investment trusts

Four of the best new investment trust listings

Diversify your portfolio and benefit from rising dividends with these four new investment trusts coming to the market soon.
15 Nov 2021
Three safe bets on the growing online gambling sector
Share tips

Three safe bets on the growing online gambling sector

Professional investor Aaron Fischer, creator of the Fischer Sports Betting and iGaming ETF, picks three of his favourite online gambling stocks.
29 Nov 2021