The French time bomb

What’s this on my doorstep? A bomb!

Okay – so it wasn’t quite the real thing – in fact it was this week’s copy of the Economist. The front page showed half a dozen trussed up baguettes and a flickering fuse-wire…

Could it be that France is the real danger at the heart of the European project?

Indeed yesterday, France’s bonds were stripped of their AAA status by yet another ratings agency – Moody’s. What’s more, Moody’s says it may cut again, citing inflexible labour markets and low levels of innovation as key problems for French competiveness. Oh, and then there is, of course, the matter of what looks like a shocking double dip recession spreading across the eurozone.

Yes folks, eurozone troubles keep piling up – and the infection is spreading deeper into the core.

Today, I want to show you a fascinating chart from CitiGroup that tells you all you need to know about Europe’s ills – and why we need to continue to tread carefully here.

What’s at stake is democracy itself.

The chart that says it all

At first sight, the chart I’m about to show you may look a bit confusing. But bear with me – it’s worth investing a few moments to understand what’s going on.

The chart shows the poll ratings for the leaders of the PIIGS nations (I’m sure you don’t need me to spell them out) through the financial crisis period. Actually, it’s not just the PIIGs, it also includes France. Oh, the French will be happy that CitiGroup saw fit to lump them in with the so-called peripherals!

Eurozone leaders approval ratings chart

You’ll notice that new leaders come in on a high. And from there, there’s only one way to go – down!

Let’s take the green line for example. It shows Berlusconi’s gradual fall from grace. But then there’s a break in the line – that’s when Mario Monti took the reins, his rating went sky-high. But only for a while. Most politicians have some sort of a honeymoon period upon taking office.

But it’s looking like they’re very short-lived these days.  It’s all very well making promises on the campaign trail – but they’re much harder to keep once you’re in the job.

Take François Hollande. He may have come into the Élysée Palace all guns blazing, but just look at how quickly his popularity plummeted.

Looking at each country’s progression of leaders in turn is fascinating. And it highlights a serious problem at the heart of Western democracy…

Enough rope to hang us all

As Bill Clinton once famously said, “It’s the economy, stupid” and never has that been more true.

Everyone wants a slice of the economic pie. And it’s not just the welfare dependents – business is increasingly dependent on government handouts. In fact, François Hollande recently launched his “competitiveness pact”. He aims to lift output by half a percent over five years by granting €20bn a year in corporate tax relief and pruning public spending by 1%.

This is not what many voters had been expecting of their socialist leader!

The point is, in the West both industry and vast swathes of the public are hooked on government. But the only way to give to one group without having to take it from the other, is to borrow the extra cash.

And for the likes of France and the UK – they’ve been able to do that. You see, as capital has fled southern Europe, the cash has migrated north.

As money floods into French bank accounts, the banks use much of the cash to buy French government bonds (for safety, you know!). And so the yields on government debt are down to just over 2%.

It’s just the same as here in the UK – perceived safety allows government borrowing to continue to rise. None of the hard-core austerity for us lot… and precious little rioting in the street too.

Let’s enjoy the endgame

The thing is, neither stimulus (more borrowing), nor austerity have shown any meaningful and sustainable impact on our listless economies. Despite the best efforts of the politicians to spend and borrow, or indeed make cuts, the opinion polls still point downhill.

The truth is wholesale reform is required. And Western democracies are simply not geared up to delivering that. Or is it simply that the politicians aren’t made of the right stuff?

Who knows? But one thing’s for sure, things aren’t getting any better.

I think it was Hemingway that answered the question, “How does somebody go bankrupt?” Answer: “Slowly at first… then, all of a sudden.”

Western nations have been gradually bankrupting themselves for decades. And though a few years of crisis may not seem like “all of a sudden” – if you take the long-view, things are coming to a head pretty quick.

There’s no easy way out of the funk we find ourselves in. It’s now pretty obvious that austerity doesn’t work. So that just leaves one option on the table. Print and spend. Yes, I know I said wholesale reform was another option – but so long as there are opinion polls, that seems highly unlikely. Doing things right will cause too much pain.

On the bright side, print and spend policies don’t need to be bad for investing.

I expect that today’s short-term economic policies will be ruinous over the long run. Not least because they’re not helping to get the economy back on track anyway. But over the short term, I welcome the money printers with open arms. There’s no doubt it’s good news for many asset classes – not least our gold. 

So let’s not get too pessimistic – keep calm and carry on. To find out more about how to help protect yourself during the endgame, click here.

• This article is taken from the free investment email The Right side. Sign up to The Right Side here.

Important Information
Your capital is at risk when you invest in shares – you can lose some or all of your money, so never risk more than you can afford to lose. Always seek personal advice if you are unsure about the suitability of any investment. Past performance and forecasts are not reliable indicators of future results. Commissions, fees and other charges can reduce returns from investments. Profits from share dealing are a form of income and subject to taxation. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and may be subject to change in the future. Please note that there will be no follow up to recommendations in The Right Side.

The Right Side is an unregulated product published by Fleet Street Publications Ltd.

Fleet Street Publications Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. FSA No 115234. http://www.fsa.gov.uk/register/home.do

5 Responses

  1. 21/11/2012, John wrote

    In a democracy politicians must bribe the voter with tax cuts , welfare payments etc to get elected.

    So expenditure ratchets up and up. And people depend on the state more and more.
    Eventually the system collapses. Simple

  2. 21/11/2012, Noel Falconer MEcon wrote

    Astronomic amounts of money have been injected into the economy, in cunning ways that allegedly will avoid inflation. They will. We’ll jump it to the HYPER variety, which differs – far! – worse than does dysentry from a minor case of the skitters. All the lies can only delay this. US President Lincoln – ‘Honest Abe’, who wasn’t so knew what he was talking about – warned us, ‘You cannot fool all the people all of the time’.

    There’s no cure, not at this stage, nor any hiding place, gold and all its analogues will surely be confiscated.

  3. 21/11/2012, Chevron 39 wrote

    I comment very infrequently but I must say I have been saying for over two years to my investment friends and advisers that France is the next to go. With over 50% of workers paid directly or indirectly by the state it is a wonder that they were held in such high esteem.
    One scenario not suggested for solving the Euro-crisis is the abolition of the Euro or a creation of a Northern Euro. The Southern States would devalue making them competitive in the world market. The Northern-Euro would increase in value making their exports more in line with world markets. This would be of advantage to Britain and US but disadvantage to Germany and other northern states. They have had it too good for too long. The original Euro entry rates were rigged for the German advantage.
    Once this difficult re-a lineament is concluded the world economy will return to normal.

  4. 22/11/2012, William wrote

    The answer to fix an economy in ruins that Bengt Saelensminde and all the Western politicians are trying so hard to avoid is the age-old one, namely, to liquidate people and loot their resources, and to employ the unemployable by making war on a neighbouring State as a means in achieving this end.

  5. 22/11/2012, Jim wrote

    I’ll hold your coat.473

Commenting on this article closed

MoneyWeek magazine

Latest issue:

Magazine cover
Hard cash

What's next for gold and silver?

The UK's best-selling financial magazine. Take a FREE trial today.
Claim 4 FREE Issues
Shale gas 'fracking' promises to transform Britain's energy market. Find out what it is, what it means, and how to invest.

More from MoneyWeek

FREE REPORT:
What you should really do with your money (2014 Edition)


How to buy and sell penny shares

A beginner's guide to investing in gold

How to invest in British fracking