Is it time to buy Tesco?

Tesco: can you trust the Bollinger bands?

I’ve made the argument for Tesco as my favoured supermarket play over recent months. More than that, I believe it could be an internet giant. I guess it’s the contrarian in me. Give me a sector and a stock in the doghouse, and there’s a good chance I’ll be running the slide rule over the business.

But it’s more than just being contrarian. It strikes me that Tesco is the only supermarket major with a vision for what they term “multi-channel” retailing. I’ve already made my thoughts clear on Morrisons’ divisive price attack on the industry. Financing a price war by mortgaging your property estate looks like a bit of a gamble to me.

So, I like Tesco. A couple of months back, I showed you a simple tool that I use all the time to help locate a sensible in-price. And that is the Bollinger band. Today, I’m going to see what Bolly bands tell us about Tesco shares.

If you’re considering a position in Tesco, then you’ll want to get your timing right. After all, contrarian plays are rarely slam-dunks.

What Bolly bands tell us about Tesco

The Bollinger band is a simple chart overlay (available on most online charting packages) that plots out a stock’s trading range.

The essential advice is, don’t buy a stock at the top of its band. We looked at IG index at the time. A great business, going great guns. But the last thing I wanted you to do was to chase the stock higher.

IG was trading at about £6.30, and the chart suggested to me that it should drop to around £6.20 (about a third off the top of the Bolly band). And that turned out to be true. There were at least two opportunities to buy sub-£6.20 over the last couple of months. That’s a decent discount, and certainly worth having.

Right. But in the case of Tesco, there’s no talk of chasing the stock higher. On the contrary, as the following chart shows, this one is trading near the bottom of its Bollinger range, certainly not the top.

So the question is, can we still use our Bolly bands to help with our timing?

Tesco share price chart with Bollinger bands

The blue Bolly range shows us where a share price ‘should’ trade (statistically speaking) with 95% accuracy. In that sense, it’s better to buy when the stock is nearer the bottom of its range.

While it’s a great way of getting your short-term timing right, it’s certainly not a fool proof strategy for long-term investment. This chart shows that.

Despite hitting the bottom of the band many times, it continued to trace lower, and lower… and lower. As the share drops, it just drags the Bollinger band down with it.

Pick your ‘bottom-fishing’ strategy

The band is nonetheless useful for bottom-fishing these types of turnaround plays. At first sight, there’s certainly a lot of overhead blue sky on the chart. If the price returns towards the top of its band (which is not uncommon), then there could be an easy 10% profit in store.

However, given the sentiment surrounding the industry, we probably shouldn’t get too excited about a quick rebound. What’s more likely to happen is that Tesco will settle in its new range. As the price remains at this level, so it will establish a tighter and lower Bollinger band. And as it does, we can use the band as a guide to a decent entry point.

Attacking the ‘bottom-fishing’ problem this way will hopefully keep us from making a mistake. If the price continues to chase lower, then at least we’re not losing money. We’re not sucked in before another precipitous fall.

Playing the waiting game is the safest strategy – but it may mean you miss the absolute price low. That’s why less risk-averse investors will just pile in anyway. With a well-covered dividend prop, there’s no doubt in my mind that anything sub-three quid is good value.

Then again, there’s no doubt, I’ve got myself wet on these bottom-fishing expeditions in the past. The safe play is to wait and let the stock establish a new range. Then buy when the price hits the bottom. The more carefree approach says “Just buy”, it’s cheap!

Horses for courses, as they say. Whatever way investors choose to play it, it’ll be interesting to see how the band develops.

FREE daily investment email from MoneyWeek
Receive our thought-provoking investment email Money Morning every weekday morning, plus occasional promotions, & become a smarter investor.

Please enter a valid email address

To sign up, enter your email address:

[xyz_lbx_custom_shortcode id=10]

• Stay up to date with MoneyWeek: Follow us on TwitterFacebook and Google+

  • mikey

    Interesting (if your chart is correct) that volume is very big at the recent low – should be significant ….

  • B Glass

    In Ireland Lidl and Aldi seem to be growing all the time.. It is not just that it is budget shopping but they have interesting themes every week with good products from the continent. As a bit of a gourmand I really enjoy their selections for example this evening it is a hare casserole made with with fillets from Lidl. Tesco does not offer such delights despite it’s great size. These german competitors offer quality produce at reasonable prices. I think Tesco will not recover it’s price unless it changes the weekly specials to tempt customers.

  • Arkiruthis

    Well, Lidl and ALDI are private companies and unlisted on the stock markets (as far as I am aware!). Also, I’m not sure that they would ever be listed, the owners being quite happy with their stake.

    I think Tesco has the potential (and heavyweight clout) to get in on more online ordering and try and take some of Amazon’s pie. I don’t think any of the others can even get close on this front. Also, Tesco is still recovering from it’s cross-Atlantic mistakes. I’m still happy to keep it in there for the decent dividend, if nothing else, for a long time.

  • Quant

    Bought Sainsburys at 374 or so (just prior to King’s resignation!) and sitting on a bit of a loss now. But hefty dividend, delicious own label product range and property assets have kept me holding faith. I tend to not sell stocks easily so will be interesting to see where we are in a few years time.

  • G J M

    Interestingly, my wife,the shopper, says although we have moved from Morrisons to Tesco, she has come to the conclusion that fish and meat tastes better from Morrisons although we first shop for fruit and veg at Aldi. So look out Tesco, the ladies have the vote!

  • Russell Bruce

    Hi Bengt

    Think I got in as Tesco was bottoming out – for the moment anyway

    The share price has taken a knock and it is not clear just why. The half year to Nov shows healthy assets and cash as they continue to invest. The drop in grain sales for the 6 months is disappointing and not made up by growth in other product lines.

    They have a good story, but this is a high risk investment. So, in your opinion, does this look a good time to add to holdings or bail out?

  • Pinkers Post

    Tesco is a value trap. Neil Woodford was right in ditching his holding soon after the first profit warning, saying it’s a “super tanker’ and will take a LONG time to turn around, if at all. Instead ‘Snap up Sainsbury’s!

MoneyWeek magazine

Latest issue:

Magazine cover
Cleaning up

Profiting from the fight against pollution

The UK's best-selling financial magazine. Take a FREE trial today.
Claim 4 FREE Issues

Which investment platform?

When it comes to buying shares and funds, there are several investment platforms and brokers to choose from. They all offer various fee structures to suit individual investing habits.
Find out which one is best for you.

29 May 1660: Charles II restored to the throne  

While Charles II was formally proclaimed King by parliament in April, he only reached London on this day in 1660.

The Kids' Portfolio: the four best funds to buy for your children

Investing for your children's long-term future is an excellent idea. But what should you buy? The Kids' Portfolio is a simple collection of four funds intended to be tucked away for 20 to 40 years.