Populist challengers are as bad as the elite

Douglas Carswell holding a copy of Rebel © Rex Features
A new manifesto for change – or the same old libertarian fare?

Cover of RebelRebel: How To Overthrow The Emerging Oligarchy
by Douglas Carswell
Published by Head of Zeus, £18.99
(Buy at Amazon)

Douglas Carswell has had an eventful few years. After moving from the Conservatives to Ukip in August 2014, he managed to hold his seat at both the subsequent by-election, and the 2015 general election. However, his libertarian views sat uneasily with Nigel Farage’s populist approach, and the two have clashed over a wide range of issues, culminating in his recent decision to quit Ukip and become an independent MP.

Carswell’s new book, Rebel, is an attempt to outline his political philosophy. In it, he argues that the current establishment, both political and business, is corrupt and deliberately constructed so as to avoid public scrutiny. This isn’t a particularly new idea: you can hear variations on this theme from everyone from Beppe Grillo in Italy to Donald Trump in America. However, the big twist is that Carswell thinks that the populist challengers to the status quo, such as Trump, Grillo and Farage, are just as bad as the elite that they are trying to replace.

Indeed, Carswell is particularly scathing about the Ukip leader. Rather than trying to change, or at least reform, the system, these politicians are only concerned with trying to grab more power for themselves, he says, using fear and hysteria to further their own interests.

Instead of trying to replace the people at the top, Carswell thinks that we need to make some fundamental changes to the way that we regulate business and finance. We need to avoid following the example of medieval Venice and early modern China, where entrepreneurial activity and businesses ended up being enmeshed in a web of regulation designed to maintain the elite’s stranglehold on power. This led to stagnation and decline, while countries that stayed open to innovation, such as 16th-century Holland and 19th-century Britain, became economic superpowers.

This is all heady stuff. But look closely and much of Carswell’s programme is standard libertarian fare, such as dismantling the welfare state, replacing public services with personal savings accounts, and breaking up the BBC.

Such policies would accentuate inequality without stimulating enterprise, and would make the oligarchy even more powerful. His idea of growing UK-US trade by accepting US standards also deliberately overlooks the fact that US standards are much weaker than ours. Finally, some of the stranger ideas he puts forward include ending limited liability for bankers and having multiple currencies circulate in the UK at the same time. These proposals are simply unworkable in a modern economy.


Claim 12 issues of MoneyWeek (plus much more) for just £12!

Let MoneyWeek show you how to profit, whatever the outcome of the upcoming general election.

Start your no-obligation trial today and get up to speed on:

  • The latest shifts in the economy…
  • The ongoing Brexit negotiations…
  • The new tax rules…
  • Trump’s protectionist policies…

Plus lots more.

We’ll show you what it all means for your money.

Plus, the moment you begin your trial, we’ll rush you over THREE free investment reports:

‘How to escape the most hated tax in Britain’: Inheritance tax hits many unsuspecting families. Our report tells how to pass on up to £2m of your money to your family without the taxman getting a look in.

‘How to profit from a Trump presidency’: The election of Donald Trump was a watershed moment for the US economy. This report details the sectors our analysts think will boom from Trump’s premiership, and gives specific investments you can buy to profit.

‘Best shares to watch in 2017’: Includes the transcript from our roundtable panel of investment professionals – and 12 tips they’re currently tipping. The report also analyses key assets, including property, oil and the countries whose stock markets currently offer the most value.