Investors are feeling cheerful – time to batten down the hatches

Last week, I got a rather worrying phone call.

I was asked to talk to BBC Radio Scotland about whether it was time for listeners to think about “getting back into the stock market”. It wasn’t for a financial show either – it was a general magazine programme.

Why is that worrying? There’s a saying in the markets: “if it’s in the press, it’s in the price.” In other words, if a financial trend is hitting the headlines, it’s probably nearing the end of its life.

So when the BBC phones up and asks if it’s time to ‘take a punt’ on the markets again, just as the FTSE 100 is nearing its all-time high, you can see why I might start to fear for the staying power of this bull market…

When everyone else is bullish, it’s time to worry

Investors – as a group – are awful at timing the market. They buy just as the market is about to tumble. They watch it drop all the way. When they can bear the pain of loss no longer, they bail out. Then it recovers.

I’m sure anyone with any experience of investment recognises this mistake from bitter experience – I know I do. ‘Retail’ or small investors are often seen as being the most prone to this error. But that’s unfair – institutional investors are terrible at timing the market too.

A recent academic paper has provided yet more evidence of just how terrible. It’s a study by Harvard behavioural economists, Robin Greenwood and Andre Shleifer.

They looked at surveys of investor sentiment – ways to measure how optimistic (bullish) or pessimistic (bearish) investors are feeling. These surveys reflect investors’ actions pretty well. In other words, when investors are feeling upbeat, they put more money in stocks.

But what is it that makes investors feel optimistic about stocks in the first place? Is it because they’re cheap? After all, history shows that in the long run, if you buy markets when they’re cheap, you’ll make more money.

As Warren Buffett didn’t quite put it, you want to buy beefburgers when they’re doing a BOGOF deal at the supermarket, not when they’re full price. (Of course, you also want to make sure you’re actually getting beef. We could stretch out into a whole metaphor on balance sheet due diligence, but I’ll leave that for now.)

So if we lived in a ‘rational’ world, it would make sense for investors to become more bullish as share prices fall.

Of course, that’s not the way it works. When share prices fall, people panic and worry that they’re never going to stop. So they sell. And when they rise, people panic and think that they’ll never be cheap again. So they buy.

And this is just what Greenwood and Shleifer found. As Greenwood told the Wall Street Journal: “Find any survey you can get your hands on, and they will all tell you the same thing. When prices are high and stock markets perform well, investors expect it to continue going up.”

As Gavyn Davies describes it on his FT blog, investors “chase rising stock prices and vice versa.” This is known as ‘trend-following’ when it’s done deliberately by traders, and ‘lemming-like herding activity’ when it’s done by unwary small investors.

In other words, investors buy high and sell low. So when everyone else is optimistic, you should be pessimistic. Indeed “bullish sentiment [predicted] abnormally low stock market returns over one and, especially, three years ahead,” notes Davies.

Given that investors are currently very optimistic, this suggests you should be wary.

Stick with your plan, but take profits on speculative punts

So what can you do? I’m not for a minute saying that you should pull all your money out of stocks. Apart from anything else, you don’t know exactly when or how far stocks will correct. Markets could easily see a 10-15% drop from here without it being too significant in the longer run.

But what I am saying is that you should be wary of getting carried away by everyone else’s optimism. When all around you are screaming ‘buy’ and talking of the great returns to be made on this or that investment, it’s hard to keep your eye on the prize.

You should already have a plan for your investing. So stick to it. Keep drip-feeding your money into cheap markets such as Europe and Japan. Keep reinvesting your dividends. Don’t worry too much about what everyone else is thinking – regular rebalancing of your portfolio will stop you from being caught out too badly by the swings and roundabouts of the market. (If you don’t know what rebalancing is, read this piece by my colleague Phil Oakley: How to buy low and sell high.)

All I would say is that if you have made any short-term bets with the more speculative portion of your portfolio recently, and you’re sitting on some nice gains, you might want to think about taking profits. (You know what I’m talking about – the pot of money you keep aside for following ‘make or break’ share tips and the like.)

And one last point – trend-following (chasing existing trends) can and does work, as long as you get in and out on time. As Davies notes on his FT blog, they have struggled over the past couple of years, but their long-term track record is good.

However, you shouldn’t try to time the market in this way yourself – it’s incredibly difficult and time-consuming and if you have a full-time job, you won’t be able to do it. This is one area where I’d let the experts do it for you. My colleague Tim Price recommended one specific trend-following fund in our New Year Roundtable. If you’re not already a subscriber, you can subscribe to MoneyWeek magazine.

Follow John on Twitter || Google+ John Stepek

• This article is taken from the free investment email Money Morning. Sign up to Money Morning here .

Our recommended articles for today

Why I’m not worried about this bubble

Fears have been mounting that the bond bubble may be about to burst. But this is no ordinary bubble, says Bengt Saelensminde, and the outcome may not be what you’d expect.

Should central banks target growth?

Central banks should not just aim to put a lid on inflation, but to raise growth and employment too, according to influential new thinking. Seán Keyes reports.

  • Steve

    FTSE 100 all-time high you say?

  • Willem de Leeuw

    @ Steve: I suspect John’s referring to the FTSE100 total return, i.e. including dividends.

  • Cricky

    From your very good article, I am hearing the message buy buy buy, don’t want to miss the gold rush so I am going to get in now before the markets go any higher, I can not lose !!

  • jrj90620

    I have to keep reminding myself,that I am always invested.Holding currency isn’t not being invested.Fiat currencies are the common stock of bankrupt govts.They ALWAYS decline in value,over time.Holding cash(fiat) should be only temporary,while you figure out where to exchange them for real assets.

  • FrostyA1

    Excellent article with sound perception JS.
    In objectivity it makes a refreshing change from M/W`s usual depressing `Doom & Gloom`.
    If anyone is considering heavy uploading into stocks & shares, now is not the time to do it, the only reason that the FTSE100 is on a temporary path of natural `super-erection` is the complete lack of faith in currencies, gold,oil & other boring `quick-fix viagras` but once the immediate excitement has worn off share markets will `flop & drop` towards flaccid withdrawal.
    I`ve scored well on recent Onshore & Offshore bond market share gains but I`m getting ready to abandon ship large for a safe low-interest investment to preserve this unusual`plus` when the big investor `Tarts` bail out & beach the little fish like me….F.

  • NVP

    I tend to be in the camp of Trendfollowers here and I trade what I see……so if Equities are flying then I buy them until the trend falters or ends ……and vice versa …….the rest is detail !



Claim 12 issues of MoneyWeek (plus much more) for just £12!

Let MoneyWeek show you how to profit, whatever the outcome of the upcoming general election.

Start your no-obligation trial today and get up to speed on:

  • The latest shifts in the economy…
  • The ongoing Brexit negotiations…
  • The new tax rules…
  • Trump’s protectionist policies…

Plus lots more.

We’ll show you what it all means for your money.

Plus, the moment you begin your trial, we’ll rush you over THREE free investment reports:

‘How to escape the most hated tax in Britain’: Inheritance tax hits many unsuspecting families. Our report tells how to pass on up to £2m of your money to your family without the taxman getting a look in.

‘How to profit from a Trump presidency’: The election of Donald Trump was a watershed moment for the US economy. This report details the sectors our analysts think will boom from Trump’s premiership, and gives specific investments you can buy to profit.

‘Best shares to watch in 2017’: Includes the transcript from our roundtable panel of investment professionals – and 12 tips they’re currently tipping. The report also analyses key assets, including property, oil and the countries whose stock markets currently offer the most value.