Why Britain’s fuel prices are so high

Since 2008, petrol prices have jumped beyond historic norms to hit new highs. Why? Simon Wilson reports.

Is fuel really dearer than it was?

The price of vehicle fuel in Britain has surged over the past decade, compared with its long-run average. It is now far more expensive, even in inflation-adjusted terms, than at any time since World War I.

The AA publishes a wealth of fuel price data going back to 1896, available on its website. If the data are converted into (post-decimalisation) pence per litre, it reveals that prices rise very gently for the first half of the 20th century. Prices spiked during World War I, but the cost of a litre of petrol – in nominal terms – was still only a handful of pence per litre (ppl) right up until the 1950s.

From the 1960s on, prices began to climb. At first the rise was gradual, with the price hitting 20p by the end of the 1970s and then climbing rapidly, with generally higher inflation, to pass 100p in the late 2000s. From there it has continued surging to today’s levels. The key question is why.

What about in real terms?

When inflation is taken in account, a remarkable picture emerges: throughout the 20th century, even as motoring evolved from an elite hobby into a system of mass popular transport, the price of fuel remained surprisingly stable – fluctuating within a band of around 60p to 100p (expressed in 2010 prices adjusted for inflation).

The exception was the 1914-1918 war, when prices spiked to just over 200p (in 1917) before returning to normal levels by the early 1920s. Other than that, the price of road fuel hit lows (of around 60p) in the late 1920s and late 1940s, and hit a high just above 100p in 1956, the year of the Suez crisis.

And later in the century?

From the 1950s onwards, prices trended very gently upwards, with lows (of around 75p) in the mid-1970s and again in the early 1990s, and highs (of around 100p) in 1975 and again during the early 1980s. What’s most striking, however, is what has happened over the past 20 years – namely a steady upward climb in real-terms prices, from about 75p in the early 1990s to around 110p by 2000.

For most of the 2000s, real prices then eased, and were under or around the 100p mark (in adjusted 2010 prices) until 2008. Since then, they have surged to today’s unprecedented levels of petrol prices consistently above 130p and even higher for diesel. Until about 2008, then, it was possible to argue that fuel prices, though high, were still broadly within historic norms. Now it isn’t.

So what’s going on?

Historically, the price of fuel at the pumps is closely correlated to the price of crude oil, which has surged over the past decade, and now accounts for around 40p, rather than 10p, of every litre sold. In addition, the UK government has dramatically increased the taxes it levies (in the form of fuel duty and VAT).

According to the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) report into competition in the sector, published last month, the (nominal) price of petrol paid on average at British pumps jumped from 76p in 2003 to 136p in 2012 (a rise of 79%). The jump for diesel was greater – a leap of 82% from 78p to 142p.

No wonder motorists are feeling angry and bruised. But the OFT also found that of the 60p rise in the price of petrol, 33p was made up of the rise in the cost of crude oil, and 24p was an increase in tax and duty.

How much profit does that leave?

According to the OFT’s investigation and analysis, “the margins being made by UK refiners, wholesalers and retailers do not appear to have contributed as significantly to increases in pump prices”. On petrol, the combined gross profit being made by refiners, wholesalers and retailers has risen 3.4ppl over ten years for petrol (a 14% real terms increase) and 7.2ppl for diesel (41%, much of it put down to higher profits being made by refiners due to high Europe-wide demand).

As things stand, on a litre of unleaded at today’s average cost of £1.36, 81p goes to the government, 44p is the cost of crude oil, and 11p is the combined gross margin for the refiners, wholesalers and retailers.

How does the UK compare internationally?

The OFT report cleared the industry of anti-competitive practices, such as “rocket and feather” pricing tactics (whereby prices shoot up like rockets but only fall like feathers). However, it was released to a chorus of scepticism from motoring lobby groups. Nonetheless, international comparisons do tend to add considerable weight to the claim that British prices are high due to high taxes rather than industry sharp practice.

Before tax, Britain has one of the cheapest petrol prices of the 27 EU states, but after tax it’s one of the most expensive. When it comes to diesel, the picture is even more stark: before tax Britain has the fifth cheapest diesel in the EU, but after tax it is easily the most expensive. Only Italy and Sweden come close.

What’s next for consumers?

Motorists can’t expect any more help from the Office of Fair Trading, which says there’s no basis for a more detailed investigation. Even though the number of British forecourts fell from 10,867 in 2004 to 8,677 in 2012, the OFT found retail competition remains strong, and that the growth in market share by the supermarkets (from 29% to 39%) has helped keep prices low.

It will look into local cases of alleged anti-competitive practices, such as in the Western Isles of Scotland, where competition is minimal. It also found that on average prices are 8p higher at motorway service stations, and called for road signs displaying prices to drivers before they pull in.

5 Responses

  1. 14/02/2013, John Brown wrote

    My 13-year old Combo diesel van is still running well and costing only a little to maintain. But this can’t last for ever, even with just 113,000 miles on the clock.
    Diesel seems a bad bet for a newish vehicle, because of the need for a particulate filter, that is only cleaned properly at near-motorway speeds, which I hardly ever do.

    So I am thinking in terms of a petrol/LPG Combo, from around 2004 or 2005. People warn me that the government will only put up the tax on LPG, destroying the advantage. But will they destroy the tax advantage, given the likelihood of more domestic natural gas from shale under Lancashire, and perhaps imports from the USA where gas prices are is it a quarter of European prices? They ought to have half an eye to our balance of payments.

  2. 14/02/2013, John Brown wrote

    contd.
    The difference between 80p. on petrol, and whatever the tax is on LPG, might take a while for the government to swallow back. There is an interesting graph of LPG prices at
    http://www.whatgas.com/petrol-prices/lpg-prices.html
    where they say that in 2009 LPG was taxed at 16p. compared to 64p. for petrol. I do not know the current differential.

    Jim Jubak says that Cheniere (US stock symbol LNG) has French contracts for LPG on which to base its investment in a liquifaction plant, which is I think is 2 years from completion. Are UK importers locked into long-term contracts with Qatar?
    The UK government has just committed to lots more gas-fired power stations, so where are they intending to get the LPG from? This seems to be an arcane topic that nobody discusses.

  3. 14/02/2013, Rajah Brooks wrote

    I always drive LPG / petrol hybrids. I got back from 16 months in south america in March and found in that time LPG had gone up between 30% and 40%. Considering that it’s cleaner, LPG gets shockingly little support from the government…probably precisely because they don’t earn as much in tax from it. Our nearest LPGs stations are 20 miles away in one direction and 30 in the other. Stations that used to provide it are giving up on it all the time.

  4. 17/02/2013, John Brown wrote

    Rajah,
    Thanks for the info. I have just been comparing the graph of LPG prices against one for petrol, at
    http://www.whatgas.com/petrol-prices/unleaded-prices.html

    They look to follow each other quite closely, in percentage terms, and petrol shows a 60% rise from Jan 2009 up to today, whilst LPG shows 50%. March 2012 was a local peak for both fuels. Web sites do report great variability in LPG prices.

  5. 17/02/2013, John Brown wrote

    contd.
    What you report on vanishing LPG stations is quite worrying, and I will do a web-survey before deciding finally whether to ditch diesel. I suppose I could buy a 2005 diesel and spend a little on the brakes etc., which seem to wear fast because of the engine weight. One Web article says legislation required the filters from 2009.

    For a band-D vehicle with Co2 emission of 120, if registered after 2001, tax costs £100 per year, compared to £220 for my old van. Then in 2010, by which time you had to have a filter, tax dropped to £0.
    So I think I should aim to buy a good diesel up to 2009, losing £100 in tax against a newer vehicle, but not having a filter.

Commenting on this article closed

MoneyWeek magazine

Latest issue:

Magazine cover
Hard cash

What's next for gold and silver?

The UK's best-selling financial magazine. Take a FREE trial today.
Claim 4 FREE Issues
Shale gas 'fracking' promises to transform Britain's energy market. Find out what it is, what it means, and how to invest.

More from MoneyWeek

FREE REPORT:
What you should really do with your money (2014 Edition)


How to buy and sell penny shares

A beginner's guide to investing in gold

How to invest in British fracking