Brace yourself for another panic over China

Supermarket in China © Getty Images
China’s private-sector debt is 210% of GDP

China has too much debt.

There are few areas in economics that pretty much everyone agrees on, but this is one of them.

The level of debt the country is carrying puts it at risk of a 2008-style shock or Japanese-style perma-deflation.

So it should be good news that Chinese leader Xi Jinping has said that he wants to crack down on leverage. And it is.

Trouble is, while curing China’s debt addiction is a worthy long-term goal, it’s hard to see how it can avoid incurring short-term pain to get there…

You can’t get there from here

As Diana Choyleva of Enodo Economics puts it, China’s “debt to GDP is approaching uncharted territory and the authorities can no longer sweep bad loans under the carpet”.

At a whopping 210%, private sector, non-financial debt in China is now higher (as a percentage of GDP) than it was in Korea ahead of its 1997 crisis, and it’s nearly at the levels seen in Japan ahead of the 1989 bubble and bust.

So it would be better for China if its debt position were a little less precarious. The multi-trillion-yuan question, of course, is: “how do you get there from here?”

Credit makes the world go around, as Liza Minnelli didn’t quite put it. The problem is that, in general, the more debt you have, the more you have to spend for every $1 of genuine growth. If you don’t have much debt, then adding a little can really juice up your returns. But if your economy is already swamped with it, you have to add a lot to get just a little extra growth.

China is still growing rapidly. But its growth rate has halved from its pre-financial crisis levels. And the risk is that just throwing further money at the problem spurs inflation rather than helping growth.

For example, notes Choyleva, the Chinese government “stimulated” the economy at the start of 2016 (partly in response to the fear rattling markets at the time). “Growth surged in the quarter, but house price inflation picked up speed immediately.”

The good news is that “Beijing understands that putting off dealing with bad loans and using banks… to bankroll spending sprees… will no longer work”. The bad news is that, even in a system where the banks are basically just arms of the government, it’s not easy to engineer a “soft landing”.

The plan is to clean up the system by allowing capitalism to creep into the process. Monetary policy is being tightened. Some over-indebted companies will be bailed out, but others will be allowed to fail.

Of course, that’s easier said than done – akin to “changing the engine while the car is still running”, says Choyleva.

As UBS analysts put it: “it could lead to a rise in credit events, excessive liquidity tightening, faster-than-intended slowdown of credit growth, and greater market volatility”.

Markets are showing early signs of concern about China

None of this should come as a surprise. Of course it’s difficult to unwind a centrally planned economy in favour of something more market-orientated. Particularly when you simultaneously want to maintain a pretty tight grip on the social reins.

If you are under any illusion that this should be easy, just think how jittery our own “free market” economies get every time our premier economic planning institutions – the central banks – threaten the teensiest little interest rate rise, or a gentle slowdown in the rate of money printing.

Our policymakers reckon they have a lot of balls to keep in the air. But China is juggling with fiery chainsaws by comparison.

An overvalued exchange rate. Capital flight. A state-owned banking system choked with bad debts from state-owned corporations. A shadow banking system full of high-risk investment products used mostly by members of the Communist party, who would be very unhappy about a systemic collapse wiping out their investments.

Trying to reform all that lot without any sort of upheaval is downright impossible.

Markets are only just waking up to this. Miners and commodities had an amazing year last year, but prices have started to come off the boil. Commodity prices are slipping back, the mining sector peaked in February, and of course, oil prices are on the slide again.

Not coincidentally, the Shanghai Composite Index has been slipping back over the past fortnight. Simon Derrick of BNY Mellon tells the FT: “While the forces driving the recent equity market weakness in China and oil are seemingly unconnected, it’s nevertheless noticeable that the major turning points for both have tended to coincide over the past two years.”

So what’s next? On the one hand, commodities and the mining sector came a very long way in 2016. It’s no surprise that they might need a breather.

On the other, if there is another panic over China – and it feels as though one is brewing – then there could be further declines to come. And there’s no doubt that a lot of the “excess” money in the Chinese system has gone into commodity stockpiling and property speculation.

Of course, if fears over China rear up again, the rest of the market will have to catch up with the commodities sector. In short, we might get some interesting opportunities arising before too long.

  • Horiboyable .

    Can you imagine China melting down at the same time as the west’s bond bubble collapses. That will be a sight for sore eyes.

    • quark

      I like panic. It brings opportunity.

  • jaizan

    The Chinese currency cannot possibly be considered overvalued when it is at a level which still allows them to undercut every other major economy on the prices of exported manufactured goods. That is what most people consider undervalued.

  • Bennet

    i like what @disqus_kMyyK5b36J:disqus said, and i agree… panics or declines are opportunities in the making….i agree that China was in deep debt right now, and for those skeptical investors, there are factors that suggest that right now is the time investing in Chinese stocks….

  • smspf

    In the end GBP will devalue against the CNY.

Merryn

Claim 12 issues of MoneyWeek (plus much more) for just £12!

Let MoneyWeek show you how to profit, whatever the outcome of the upcoming general election.

Start your no-obligation trial today and get up to speed on:

  • The latest shifts in the economy…
  • The ongoing Brexit negotiations…
  • The new tax rules…
  • Trump’s protectionist policies…

Plus lots more.

We’ll show you what it all means for your money.

Plus, the moment you begin your trial, we’ll rush you over THREE free investment reports:

‘How to escape the most hated tax in Britain’: Inheritance tax hits many unsuspecting families. Our report tells how to pass on up to £2m of your money to your family without the taxman getting a look in.

‘How to profit from a Trump presidency’: The election of Donald Trump was a watershed moment for the US economy. This report details the sectors our analysts think will boom from Trump’s premiership, and gives specific investments you can buy to profit.

‘Best shares to watch in 2017’: Includes the transcript from our roundtable panel of investment professionals – and 12 tips they’re currently tipping. The report also analyses key assets, including property, oil and the countries whose stock markets currently offer the most value.